|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Sourcebook of
Alternative Technologies for Freshwater Augmentation in West Asia>
2. Water Quality Improvement Technology
The limited freshwater resources in most of the Arab countries of West Asia was the impetus
to search for sources to help satisfy the increasing water demands, especially
for drinking and domestic purposes. This is a primary rationale
for all the Gulf countries to expand their construction of seawater
desalination plants, as well as to expand their activities in desalinization of
highly-saline groundwater. There is no doubt that the availability of energy at a reasonable cost,
as well as the expansion of many residential concentrations near coastal areas, has
facilitated the expansion of seawater desalination plants in these
countries. Further, the countries have concluded that transporting natural water over long distances
to supply such residential communities is very costly, compared to desalination of saline water.
Tin a reasonable cost, in addition to the spread of most of the residential
concentrations near the coast, has helped these countries to expand in establishing seawater
desalination plants. These countries have also realized that transporting natural water for
long distances to supply these residential communities is costly, compared to
the desalination of saline water.
Water desalination technologies have been used in the Gulf countries for a half
century, with their use expected to multiply in the next 20-25 years,
increasing at the rate of about 7%, based on data from International Atomic
Energy Agency (IAEA, 1999). The production of the desalinated water in the Gulf countries currently
comprises about 60% of the total volume of desalinated water in the world. For the rest of the West
Asia region countries, the use of desalination technology is still limited, primarily
because of the high costs. The estimated volumes of desalinated water in Jordan is 3.08
million m3/year, Syria - 2.00 million m3/year, Iraq - 121.00 million
m3/year, Lebanon - 1.70 million m3/year, and Yemen - 5.00 million
m3/year.
At the same time, the use of wastewater, including drainage water of all types, is also
starting to attract the attention of the Arab countries of West Asia, as a
means of augmenting freshwater resources. The construction of sanitary drainage water treatment
plants (and agricultural drainage on a smaller scale) has increased, and the water is being
used to irrigate some agricultural crops and green fields, and to artificially
recharge groundwater. Use of this water source for domestic purposes is still limited because
of health and social considerations. The quantity of treated
wastewater in the West Asia region is estimated to be about 362.2 million m3/year
(ACSAD, 1997). Expansion of the reuse of treated sanitary drainage water will doubtless become
an essential strategic choice, especially in view of the large quantities of water needed
for domestic purposes.
It also is noted that artificial groundwater recharge technologies, using treated sanitary
drainage water or floodwater, will help improve its water quality, due
primarily to infiltration of the water through the permeable soil separating
the aquifer from the ground surface. Injection of freshwater into brackish groundwater aquifers
also improves its quality. The injected freshwater is typically from conventional sources or
from the excess water production of desalination plants.
2.1 Water Desalination Technologies
Water desalination technologies can be categorized on the basis of the energy used to run them,
usually thermal or electric. The technologies utilizing
thermal energy are known as the multi-stage flash (MSF), multiple-effect
distillation (MED) and vapor compression (VC). The desalination technologies that use electric
energy rely on a membrane system, such as reverse osmosis (RO) and electro dialysis (ED).
There also are other technologies that rely on solar energy or combined electric and thermal energy.
Each of these technologies has advantages and disadvantages, based on the quantity and quality of
the required water and the location. The distributon of the
different technologies among the countries of the West Asia region is outlined
in Table 9. The multi-stage flash
technology (Figure 42) is the most-used technology for the Arabian
Peninsula. Table 9 also illustrates the
types, capacities and numbers of desalination plants in a number of Arab
countries, as well as the technologies being used (Tayseer Dabagh and Ahmed
Belhag, 1997).
Table 9. Types, capacities and number of desalination
plants in some countries of the West Asia region
|
Country |
Type of technology |
Total |
Number of units |
|
MSF |
RO |
Others |
|
Saudi Arabia |
3,449 |
1,627 |
177 |
5,253 |
1,137 |
|
Emirates |
1,944 |
140 |
80 |
2,165 |
169 |
|
Kuwait |
1,469 |
52 |
17 |
1,538 |
69 |
|
Qatar |
510 |
3 |
- |
513 |
6 |
|
Bahrain |
161 |
129 |
19 |
309 |
111 |
|
Oman |
162 |
23 |
8 |
193 |
59 |
|
Yemen |
- |
- |
75 |
75 |
22 |
|
Iraq |
11 |
233 |
89 |
333 |
110 |
| Source: Dabbagh, T.A. and Ahmed Belhag
Farag. (1997)
|
|
N.B.
| The values for Qatar were updated by Qatar representative
participating in the seminar for Preparation of the Source Book of the
Alternative Technologies for the Augmentation of Freshwater in West Asia.
|
2.1.1 Distillation Desalination (DD)
Distillation desalination is considered one of the oldest technologies used in desalination of
seawater and saline water. It was developed over several decades, and
several different technologies have evolved from it, including multi-stage
flash (MSF), multiple-effect distillation (MED) and vapor compression (VC). This has facilitated the
widespread use of the seawater distillation desalination technology.
Figure 42. Annual capacity of desalination plants in the
Gulf countries
Multi-Stage Flash Desalination (MSF)
Technology Description
This technology is based on passing the water to
be desalinated into a container and heating it to high temperatures, causing it
to boil and the pressure in the container to decrease. A part of the water flashes to a vapor
stage, while the rest of the hot water continues flowing through a series of
chambers or stages. These chambers exhibit gradually-decreasing temperatures and pressures, leading
to the transformation of the water into vapor (the pressure in each chamber is
maintained at values less than the level of saturated vapor pressure). With this procedure,
the water loses some of its salt in each stage, and the salt remains with the residuals.
The vapor is then condensed, transforming it
into liquid freshwater. This technology
requires the water to pass through at least 20-25 chambers, and the
desalination efficiency improves with increasing numbers of chambers (Figure
43). The cost of the initial construction works, as well as the economic return, increases
with the number of chambers. The first system to employ
this technology was established in Kuwait in 1977. Since then, its use has increased to about
70% of the total desalination plants. Despite introduction of a new technology in the early-1990’s,
50% of the plants still use the MSF method. It has a high recovery rate in producing freshwater
(less than 30 particles/million). The required temperatures ranges between 90-110 degrees.
Figure 43. Multi-stage flash desalination process
The MSF technology is one of most popular systems in the Gulf countries, with the
existing installed capacity of the systems being about 8.28 million m3/day.
This is approximately 72% of the desalination capacity of these countries.
Having first been used in the 1950’s, this technology represents the
oldest water desalination system used in the region.
The technology has proven its effectiveness and spread to the
other countries in the region. A feature of the technology is that it can utilize excess thermal
energy. Thus, it is possible to combine the
production of large amounts of power and water in one station, thereby
satisfying the demand for both of them. More attention is given to the distillation system,
especially because of its high durability under various conditions and its ease in treating raw
water (usually seawater), compared to the reverse osmosis method used in the
rest of the world.
Multiple-Effect Distillation Desalination (MED)
This method was widely used before the MSF method. The water is pumped through a
series of heated horizontal tubes to evaporate it.
The water usually passes outside the horizontal evaporation tube
(Figure 44), where water is sprinkled. In some small units with small capacities, the water is
evaporated inside vertical evaporation tubes (Figure 45).
The vapor resulting from each stage is condensed in the following stage,
where it can be used as a thermal source for evaporation.
Thus, the process proceeds in a chain
reaction form, with each evaporator also serving as a condenser for the vapor
resulting from the previous stage. The vapor resulting from the last stage is condensed
and released into the cooling system. Energy consumption is reduced
if the vapor pressure is captures again (thermally or mechanically) in the last
stage. The required heating temperature
is 65o C. This method has a recovery rate between 40-65%. However,
its operational and maintenance difficulties have resulted in its declining
use.
Figure 44. Conceptual diagram of horizontal-tube
multi-effect distillation process
Figure 45. Conceptual
diagram of horizontal multi-effect with vertical stacked effects
Based on the nature of the vapor production, there are few types of this technology.
Examples include Thermo-Vapor Compression (TVC) and the Mechanical Vapor Compression (MVC).
These systems can produce desalinated water in small amounts, and
they operate independently of power generation plants.
|