|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Sourcebook of Alternative Technologies for
Freshwater Augumentation in Small Island Developing States>
PART C - CASE STUDIES
5.2 Seawater/Brackish Water Desalination by Reverse Osmosis in the
British Virgin Islands
Technical Description
Desalination by reverse osmosis for public water supply is carried out
on the islands of Tortola and Virgin Gorda, British Virgin Islands (Figure
39). The operations on the island of Tortola can be classified into two
types based solely on the way the source water or feedwater is obtained.
There are three plants on the island of Tortola. At the main plant,
operated by Ocean Conversion (BVI) Ltd, the feedwater is obtained from
wells sunk at the shoreline to a depth of roughly 25 m, with a sanitary
seal from ground level to about 12 m. Water is pumped via submersible
units to the inlet of the plant. The two other plants are operated by Aqua
Design (BVI) Ltd. One uses brackish water obtained from shallow wells dug
in the
.gif)
(larger image)
Figure 39. Map of the British Virgin Islands.
alluvial deposits of the nearby valleys as feedwater, while the second,
on the western end of Tortola, uses feedwater obtained from wells drilled
at the shoreline. The two plants operating in Virgin Gorda are seawater
desalination plants and are of an open-sea intake design. In each case the
process of desalination at the plants is generally the same and can be
divided into the following elements: pre-filtration using disposable 5 æm
to 10 æm polypropylene cartridge filter elements; pressurisation to
about 7 000 kPa; separation (at an efficiency of approximately 40% for the
seawater-fed systems and 73% for the brackish water-fed systems) utilizing
spiral-wound membrane elements contained in FRP pressure vessels; pressure
recovery from the waste brine solution by means of work-exchange energy
recovery system (which significantly reduces energy usage); brine
disposal; post-treatment of the product water by means of chlorination, pH
adjustment, corrosion inhibition, such that the final water meets all WHO
standards for drinking water; metering of the product water at the exit of
the plant; and, distribution of the product water.
Extent of Use
All of the water supply areas on Tortola, and approximately 90% of the
water supply areas on Virgin Gorda, are supplied with desalinated water.
In general, the water supply covers all areas below the 90 m contour. On
Tortola, most of the south side of the Island, starting from East End and
including Beef Island to Pockwood Pond on the South West, is supplied. In
the North-West of Tortola, at Cappoons Bay, where one of the seawater
desalination plants is located, the supply covers the West End, Carrot Bay
and Cane Garden Bay areas. On the island of Tortola, there are about 4 000
water connections serving a population of 13 500 residents and a visitor
population of approximately 256 000 annually. In 1994, the Government
bought 1.2 million m3 of desalinated water from the two private companies
for distribution on the island of Tortola. On Virgin Gorda, where are two
seawater desalination plants operated by Aqua Design (BVI) Ltd., both
plants have open seawater intakes extending about 1 500 m from the
shoreline. One is in the Valley, and the other is in North Sound. These
plants serve a resident population of 2 500 and a visitor population of 49
000 annually. There are 675 water connections to the public water supply
system in Virgin Gorda. In 1994, the Government purchased 95 000 m3 of
water for distribution in Virgin Goda.
Operation and Maintenance
The major maintenance work on seawater reverse osmosis and brackish
water reverse osmosis plants consists of maintenance and repair of the
rotating equipment (consisting primarily of pumps); backwashing and
flushing of the media filters; replacement of the cartridge filter
elements (approximately every 8 weeks); cleaning of the membrane elements
(approximately every 4 months); instrument repair and calibration; general
maintenance (e.g., cleaning, painting, leak repair, cleaning around wells,
etc); replenishment of the pre- and post-treatment chemicals; and
inventory control and ordering of spare parts. In the case of the High
School plant, located in Road Town, the wells and well pumps are operated
by the Water and Sewerage Department, who conducts routine, weekly
maintenance to ensure a continuous and adequate flow of water to the
plant. Staffing levels are approximately 1 person for a 200 m3/day plant,
and up to 3 persons for a 4 000 m3/day capacity plant
Level of Involvement
Currently, all plants are operated on a BOOT (build, own, operate,
transfer) basis by private companies (generally foreign), which provide
financing, operation, and maintenance for a fixed period. The price of
water is fixed for that period by agreement with periodic adjustment for
inflation. There are penalties for non-performance. Contracts prescribe a
minimum quantity of water which the Government is obligated to buy. At two
of the five plants operating on the islands, the government Water and
Sewerage Department (WSD) is responsible for the disinfection of the final
product water. At the plants on Tortola, the WSD is responsible for the
operation and maintenance of the product water pumps at the exit of the
plants. At the brackish water plant, the WSD owns and operates the wells
that serve the plant and ensures an adequate and continuous flow of
feedwater. The ocean conversion plant, located close to the WSD head
office, has employed two technicians from the Department in the plant
operation since its commissioning. A monthly stipend is paid as part of
the contractual arrangements and these individuals are called in to assist
with repair work as and when required. The government also provides the
land, tax and custom exemptions, cost of the bulk water received, and
monitoring of the quality of the product water. The WSD distributes the
water.
Costs
The unit cost of production of desalinated water decreases as the plant
capacity increases. The turnkey capital cost of a plant of 90 m3/day is
approximately $4.5 million. The major operating costs consist of energy,
labour, membrane replacement and spare parts. Energy is the primary
operating cost, with consumption ranging from 3 to 6 KWh/m3 of potable
water produced, depending on the size of the plant and the technology
employed. Under the current purchase agreements, the companies maintain
and operate the plants at their own cost and sell water in bulk to the
government at the following rates: on Tortola, water is purchased from
Aqua Design (BVI) Ltd at a rate of $3.60/m3 for desalinated seawater and
$2.00/m3 for desalinated brackish water, and from Ocean Conversion (BVI)
Ltd at a rate of $3.50/.m3 for desalinated seawater; and, on Virgin Gorda,
water is purchased from Aqua Design (BVI) Ltd at a rate of $2.90/m3 for
desalinated seawater. The government, through the Water and Sewerage
Department, disinfects and distributes the product water. In 1994, the
government bought 1.2 million m3 of water from the desalination companies
for distribution on the island of Tortola at a cost of $3,611,000. On
Virgin Gorda, desalinated water became available to the public from
February 1994 and 95 000 m3 was bought at a cost of $485 000.
Effectiveness
of the Technology
Seawater/brackish water reverse osmosis is very effective in reducing
Caribbean seawater to potable water quality. The product water has a total
dissolved solids level of less than 500 mg/l and meets all other
requirements of the World Health Organization for drinking water.
Suitability The technology is suitable for water supply throughout the
Caribbean Basin, provided that there is a source of clean seawater, either
by means of vertical boreholes or open-sea intakes. The technology is
particularly suitable where the fresh water resources are inadequate to
meet growing demands and the centres of population are concentrated close
to the coast. In considering the end use of the desalinated water for
potable purposes, the raw water should be free from pollution, especially
from land-based industries, and the intake should be located in an area
with little chance of pollution by ocean-going vessels. The disposal of
the effluent brine should be carefully considered as this can have adverse
effects on sea life.
Advantages
Desalination is a reliable source of water that is not subjected to the
seasonal changes or locally extreme weather events associated with
freshwater sources. There is minimal use of chemicals in the process, and
the plants are modular in design and can be easily expanded. If properly
operated, there is minimal environmental impact. Delivery periods are
short, typically 3 to 12 months, depending on the location and size of
plant, and, if private contractors are used to supply the water, there is
minimum capital investment required by the government. Under such
arrangements, there is an additional advantage of a fixed water price,
linked only to inflation, for the duration of the agreement.
Disadvantages
Reverse osmosis systems require care and expertise to minimize the rate
of membrane replacement; the sophistication of plant operation require
materials and equipment of very high standard not usually available
locally resulting in high importation costs. There is usually a need for
foreign expertise and resulting loss of foreign exchange. There are also
many dissimilar components on the plants, so a highly varied spare parts
inventory is required. In the case of open-sea intakes, there is the
chance of interruptions during stormy weather.
Further Development of the Technology
The seawater/brackish water reverse osmosis would be further improved
through the development of membrane elements that are less prone to
fouling, operate at lower pressures, and require less pre-filtration; and,
of more highly efficient, energy recovery technologies that are simpler to
operate than the existing work-exchanger technology.
Information Sources
Contacts
Rajkumar Rooppchand, Engineer, Water and Sewerage
Department, Ministry of Communications and Works, British Virgin Islands.
William T. Andrews, Managing Director, Ocean Conversion
(BVI) Ltd, Post Office Box 122, Road Town, Tortola, British Virgin
Islands.
Dean Bedford, General Manager, Aqua Design (BVI) Ltd,
Post Office Box 845, Road Town, Tortola, British Virgin Islands.
Bibliography
WEDC s.d. Developing World Water. Grosvenor Press International,
London.
Government of the British Virgin Islands 1995. Development Planning
Unit Weekly Bulletins, Vol. 1, 21, 27, 28, 29, January-July, 1995.
Developing Planning Unit, British Virgin Islands.
|