Newsletter and Technical Publications
<The Councillor as Guardian of the Environment>
An
Essay and Workshop for Local Elected Leaders on Environmental Governance with
Emphasis on Adopting Environmentally Sound Technologies (ESTs) -
Training for Elected Leadership -
Part II - Workshop on the Councillor as Guardian of
the Environment - WORKSHOP -
OVERVIEW
The central challenge of the 1990s as enunciated by the Earth Summit in
Rio is to achieve sustainability. Local Agenda 21 stresses the growing
importance of local authorities as stewards of the environment. As pointed
out in the preceding essay, however, the role of the councillor as Guardian
of the Environment is complex and challenging. Few local
authorities understand much about the environmental quality of their own
areas or how their present actions and decisions affect the ability of
future generations to sustain themselves.
The workshop is to create conditions through which councillors can learn
to perform effectively as environmental guardians. At the core of the
workshop is a progressive learning process that begins with an
environmental awareness exercise and ends with a focus on how to achieve
environmentally and developmentally sustainable programmes. A principal
theme of the workshop is the relationship between development and the
environment and the recognition and use of environmentally sound
technologies as the creative link between them.
The workshop is planned with several training audiences in mind.
- One of these consists of mayors and councillors from separate local
governments. The assumption we make about these officials is that they
have not worked together and may not even know each other before
attending a Guardian of the Environment workshop. Hence,
we use the term "stranger group" to describe this training
audience.
- A second training audience consists of mayors and councillors who
serve together in the same local authorities and who are invited to
participate in the workshop as teams. For this audience we use the term
"councillor teams." The learning activities that follow were
developed on the assumption that the stranger group format will be the
most often used. We have provided the trainer with special instructions
for modifying stranger group exercises for use with councillor teams.
- A third training audience might augment the preceding audience with
department heads, other local government staff, and even community
leaders.
- A fourth training audience might consist of any of the above
combinations of participants plus officials from adjoining communities
that have or may experience similar environmental problems.
Many options are available for the use of Guardian of the
Environment workshop materials. One set of design considerations
is related to time. For example, all of the workshop components might be
used for a six consecutive training day programme (Sunday afternoon
through Saturday noon). Or, the programme might be reduced to three days
by omitting the case studies and role plays (Sunday afternoon through
Wednesday afternoon). Another possibility is to plan a series of one or
two day workshops each focusing on one or more of the components. This
format may prove more satisfactory when councillors are unwilling to be
away from home more than a couple of days at a time. Finally, one or two
of the components might be used for a short workshop before or after a
conference of local elected officials to encourage conferees to attend
longer programmes planned for a later date.
Other considerations might influence the design of Guardian of
Environment workshops.
- Environmental workshop components might be used in conjunction with
concepts, exercises and case study materials from other workshops in the
Elected Leadership Series. For example, an exercise on programme
evaluation planning in the Councillor as Overseer could be used to
provide participants with additional skills in monitoring and evaluation
to assure more successful implementation of sound environmental
technologies. Exercises included in the Councillor as Enabler and the
Councillor as Negotiator could be used to good advantage by a trainer to
give participants more skill practice opportunities with coalition
building and in using the language of negotiation to get desired results
without impairing relationships with important environmental groups.
- Workshop materials might be used to engage a single council or
councils from neighboring communities in environmental problem solving
and planning. For this purpose, the exercises on problem finding,
focusing, visioning and stakeholder analysis might be employed as a form
of environmental strategic planning with the trainer serving the
community(ies) as a consultant designer/facilitator.
- Reflection activities in Part I as might be used as group exercises.
One of the local trainers in a field test of these materials in Kenya,
for example, used reflection questions as a group exercise to identify
stakeholders.
Clearly there is considerable opportunity for trainers to improvise with
these materials in workshop design and planning.
The training activities included in this workshop anticipate the active
involvement of participants with each other and the learning concepts
presented. These activities consist of:
- Instructor presentations that provide participants with
relevant concept information at appropriate times to stimulate thinking
and reflection.
- Small group exercises designed to lead participants through a
systematic process of planning and problem solving relative to their own
environmental problems. Although the problem solving process in the
handbook is designed to move ahead sequentially, in practice
participants might start anywhere in the process, perhaps beginning with
the conception of a vision and then backwards to assess the nature of
the problem. A model illustrating the interractive nature of the various
steps in the process is shown on the next page.
- Questionnaires and checklists to assist participants in
conducting environmental self-assessments and to gather relevant data on
their respective environmental problems.
- Case studies and role plays that focus participants on
realistic, challenging situations selected to encourage reflection and
participant interaction.

Concept information is organized into "short burst"
presentations, each structured according to well-established principles of
instructional design. Rather than concentrated in one or two long
presentations, conceptual material is sequenced for delivery just prior to
or sometimes just after related skill practice or reflection activities.
We call this "just in time" presentation. This approach
emphasizes the importance of exposing participants to small amounts of
relevant concept material and then engaging them in activities that put
the new knowledge or skill to use before moving on to new material.
Strongly emphasized is the repetition of ideas and the active involvement
of participants with information being presented. Each presentation
consists of three sections. The first, focus, is to create
interest and introduce participants to the subject. The second, main
points, is the body of conceptual ideas to be covered by the trainer.
The third, review, summarizes and reinforces the ideas just
presented.
Instructions for the trainer called "trainers notes"
are provided from time to time in each presentation. Some trainers notes
encourage trainers to develop and use questions. Asking good questions at
appropriate times can stimulate participant interest, promote
understanding and encourage the back-home application of learning. Other
trainers notes suggest the reinforcement of oral presentation with visual
aids. Simple techniques include printing key points on flip chart sheets
for wall display or copying them onto transparent plates for overhead
projection. Still other trainers notes describe any advance preparations
or special materials that must be available for use by participants during
the exercise.
Other handbooks in the Training for Elected Leadership series
and various manuals published under separate cover by UNCHS (Habitat)
offer valuable guidance for trainers preparing to facilitate these and
other learning events included in this handbook.1
The preceding essay is a rich source of information on the role of the
local elected leader as environmental protector and sustainer. It is the
conceptual basis for all of the Part II workshops. Any elected official
registered to attend a Guardian of the Environment workshop
would benefit greatly by reading this essay or portions of the essay
selected by the trainer to accompany the components to be included in a
planned programme. While there is no guarantee that the materials will be
read, officials who have agreed to attend a workshop should be provided
with a copy of the selected essay materials at least one week before a
programme is scheduled to begin.
| Pre-workshop Assignment (Optional) |
Councillors registered to attend a Guardian of the Environment
workshop may be asked to complete a pre-workshop assignment. The
assignment is to identify and record information about existing and
potentially hazardous environmental problems observed during a 30 minute
walking or riding tour inside the boundaries of their local authorities.
The assignment is meant to demonstrate that environmental problems exist
in every community, and they can be identified readily by observant
councillors. Home-generated data heighten the realism and immediacy of a
workshop experience for participants. It is believed that councillors who
complete the assignment will adapt more quickly to the workshop
environment and make more effective use of the learning experience after
returning home from the training. Although many councillors may not take
the time to complete this task, we recommend that trainers include it in
their workshop designs anyway and encourage all councillors planning to
attend a workshop to bring a completed worksheet with them.
To simplify the task, councillors who are asked to complete the
assignment are furnished with a copy of the Environmental Awareness
Worksheet (see the Pre-Workshop Assignment Section of the Handbook)
several weeks in advance of the workshop.
| Alternative Design: Groups of
participants who know each other and work together might be asked to
complete the Environmental Awareness Worksheet as a group before
leaving home to attend the workshop and to bring the results with them
to the workshop. |
|