|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Planning and Management of Lakes and
Reservoirs: An Integrated Approach to Eutrophication>
CHAPTER 2. SOCIAL AND CULTURAL ASPECTS OF EUTROPHICATION
2.3. Development Status
Water Quality versus Quantity
Eutrophication problems have a special structure when they are analyzed
from the point of view of water quality and quantity. When lakes and
reservoirs are oligotrophic, water can be used for drinking, recreation,
fishing, etc. When eutrophication proceeds, species of commercial fish
change and aquaculture becomes a new enterprise. Many developing countries
have introduced the aquaculture business to local people. Aquaculture
provides food rich in animal protein to local people and funds for
fishermen. If aquaculture becomes too active, it becomes a new source of
nitrogen and phosphorus from left over food and fish urine. It is less
competitive with water supply works, recreation, cattle raising etc.,
unless blue green algae become the dominant phytoplankton in the lake or
reservoir ecosystem. Eutrophication proceeds with the gradual loss of
species diversity of the ecosystem.
The use of lake and reservoir water depends greatly on the degree of
eutrophication. When blue green algae occupy the surface of lakes and
reservoirs, water use is very limited and rehabilitation, which often
requires a large investment, is needed. Many lakes and reservoirs, in both
developing and developed countries, are at this stage. It takes a long
time to reach the eutrophication stage in a large volume of lakes and
reservoirs. However, large lakes, such as the North American Great Lakes,
Lake Victoria, and the large lakes in China, have already suffered from
eutrophication problems. The worst case of water quality versus quantity
problems can be seen in a reservoir receiving urban wastewater, while at
the same time the reservoir is used as a source of drinking water. This
situation definitely requires advanced technology for the water
purification of both drinking water and wastewater in terms of water
safety. However, this kind of situation often exists in developing
countries with a limited quantity of water. It is possible to forecast
that urbanization will rapidly progress in the metropolitan regions of
developing countries. These regions will face a severe water shortage and
eutrophication problems with surface water resources. Without a special
effort, all lakes and reservoirs that are influenced by human activity are
at the risk of eutrophication.
It is very difficult to obtain clean and safe water in the developing
countries. Rapid population growth requires increased food production,
increased convenience of life-style, and increased use of synthetic
chemicals, metals, motorized transportation, electric power, etc. All
these requirements accelerate the input of contaminants into water bodies.
However, the current value of water to people is often rooted in the past
era and cannot meet the reality of rapid changes to aquatic environments.
Classifying countries into the following four categories may help to
understand the countries that face difficulties with water-related
problems. The categories are as follows:
Category A: includes societies with a high income and access to
sufficient amounts of water.
Category B: includes societies with a high income and access to limited
amounts of water.
Category C: includes societies with a low income and access to
sufficient amounts of water.
Category D: includes societies with a low income and access to limited
amounts of water.
Countries in Category A use their economic and technological
capabilities to deal with water quality and other water-related
environmental problems. Countries in Category B likewise use money and
technology for effective solutions. However, since they have an
insufficient water supply, it is difficult for them to solve their water
problems. Countries in Categories C and D have many difficulties. Because
the former category places relatively loose restrictions on water
resources for the sake of socioeconomic development, the countries in
Category C are likely to face an increase of water pollution unless some
action is taken. Countries in Category D have a real problem: water is
already becoming a serious limiting factor in their socioeconomic
development. Whether or not a country has the economic capability, a vital
consideration is that trained people are needed to solve problems. Without
the allocation of resources for educating and training scientists and
engineers who manage water resources, there is no hope of finding
solutions for many problems.
A good illustration can be seen in Asian countries. Countries in
Category A are Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan; in Category B: Singapore,
Saudi Arabia, and Kuwait; Category C: the Philippines, Indonesia,
Cambodia, Laos, Vietnam, Malaysia, Myanmar, Iraq, and Bangladesh; and
Category D: China, India, Thailand, Iran, Pakistan, Mongolia, and Central
Asian countries.
|