|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Sourcebook of
Alternative Technologies for Freshwater Augmentation in West Asia>
Operation and maintenance
Operation and maintenance works vary on the basis of the technology used. Cisterns,
for example, are completely excavated in rocks if they are solid, or above the ground surface
where all precautions are taken to decrease water leakage from cistern walls,
contamination and wall abrasion. To increase the incoming water volume to the cistern,
the efficiency of the feeding area can be increased if it is lined with thin concrete layers or
compressed clay. Safe design specifications should be applied when computing the cross sections
of cisterns, and a suitable lining material also should be selected to minimize leakage from
the walls or the cistern bed. It is recommended that the building materials available
at the cistern site be used, as well as selecting appropriate locations for harvesting
the rainwater that guarantee the cistern is filled even during the driest periods and with the
minimum quantity of equipment.
If small dams are used, their safety depends on the basic hydrological conditions in the
watershed basin and the relevant hyrdrometric measurements, in order to determine the seasonal
water contributions for the valley or river course. The relation between the annual rainfall
rate and the runoff coefficient must be determined, and the geologic and geomorphologic conditions
at the dam site also must be identified. The dam is typically designed to sustain the
worst expected conditions. Technical management for operating the dam also is required,
as well as collection of relevant data on annual storage volume, methods of water distribution
and regular maintenance, in order to avoid negative impacts such as sedimentation at the dam
structure or spillway. The construction of small dams generally requires technical staff
with good expertise and experience, as well as the availability of modern equipment.
It is noted that Hafayer are easy to execute if they are of small capacity and
used to supply water for supplemental irrigation or livestock watering. If they are to be designed
to secure drinking water for villages or small cities, however, hydrological studies must be
conducted, including carrying out engineering works and technical supervision
during the execution and management stages of the Hafayer. The required tasks include hydrologic
studies to deter,ome the capacity of the drinking water source, exploratory surveys on
soil types and properties, and topographic surveys. A study on operation and management
of the Hafir also is required. Designs must be prepared on the Hafir water feeding system,
the water abstraction, and the protection of the stored water from contamination.
The Hafir also must be protected from occasional high floods. Other tasks include procedures
for securing water distribution through networks to the villages, and constructing
disinfection and purification units. The runoff coefficient in the water supply area also
must be improved, using conventional methods or industrial soil treatment. Evaporation losses
must be reduced with the use of floating plastic sheets, and lining also should be applied in the form
of impervious soil or plastic sheets.
Spades/streams/Mahafir are constructed using the excavated earth material around the excavated pit,
either open from two sides or one side in the direction of the water flow. Their capacity typically
does not exceed a few thousand cubic meters. They are executed either manually or mechanically,
based on available capabilities. They do not need specialized water inlet or outlet equipment,
except when the water is to be used for irrigation or agricultural purposes.
Relevant data on climate, geology and soil studies must be available for diversion dikes for
irrigation or spreading water. The soil also must also be loose in the area where the water is
to be spread, in order to increase filtration. It also should be rich in organic material.
The land slope should not exceed about 3 per thousand, and should be sufficiently uniform to
guarantee a wide spreading of the water. The water spreading area should be large with no major
protrusions. Water-spreading dams and dikes also require periodic maintenance to ensure long
operational lives. A study on the quantity and types of deposited sediments transported annually
also is recommended. An accurate study on the hydrologic conditions in the suggested area for the
dam and the water spreading area, including an estimation of the maximum and minimum water flows,
also is recommended. It is also important to study the locations of the water inlets and outlets,
to ensure the easy distribution and spreading of water in the proposed area. In regard to dikes,
a suitable means of conveying water to reduce water losses should be developed, either through
construction of earth channels lined with plastic or cement, or construction of suspended concrete
channels or plastic pipes.
Level of Involvement
Runoff water harvesting technologies have been known for a long time. Attention to these
technologies, however, has increased in recent years as a result of a depletion in groundwater
resources because of increasing water demands, particularly from wells. This increased attention
also is a result of an increasing awareness of the importance of utilizing all available water
resources, including rainwater, to meet various development requirements.
It is clear that the involvement of all the governments in the region in
expanding the relevant structures is essential, particularly for constructing
small dams. This technology is becoming increasing utilized in countries where it is showing promise.
The support shown by governments in regard to cisterns and Hafayer, however, is limited.
As a result, local people typically carry out the construction and
maintenance work at their own expense, although they have limited areas in such
cases.A number of such projects have
been implemented in various countries in the region, including Jordan and
Syria, with the goal of increasing the use of harvested runoff water. The latter are primarily
research projects carried out in cooperation between the governments and international
organizations.Some governments still supervise the execution of cisterns and the distribution
of their water in accordance with specific regulations. The efforts exerted by the government
of Yemen in construction of water storage structures is illustrated in Table 2.
Cost
It is difficult to estimate the cost per cubic meter for the water provided
through the various technologies of runoff water harvesting illustrated in the
previous sections.Accurate estimates depend on such variables as the conditions of the area,
the volume of the facility and the extent of water use. Some studies suggest that the construction
cost of the cisterns is between US$ 25-40/m3.If well executed, their operational
lifetime will be virtually unlimited due to the low maintenance costs.
Table 2. Government-funded small-scale storage structures in Yemen
On the other hand, the construction cost of small dams is somewhat high.The construction
cost of a dam with a storage capacity of about 1.0 million m3 of water is estimated
to be US$ 400,000 (US$ 0.4/m3). In Palestine, the cost of constructing an
agricultural catchment pond of a volume of 3,000 m3 is about US$
25,000, including the cost of the land with an area of about 5,000 m2. The cost of
constructing an agricultural catchment pond of a volume of 250 m3 in Gaza, using
prefabricated concrete, is estimated to be about US$ 6,100. If it is considered that the estimated
life span of the structure is at least 20 years, it is clear that the bitumen pits are cheaper
that metal tanks used for the same purpose.
Effectiveness of the Technology
The efficiency of this technology depends primarily on the benefits achieved because of its
execution.The rainwater harvesting projects executed in Jordan, for example, such as improving
the Al-Hammad basin (A-Rowaished- 50 mm rainfall/year), resulted in improvement of
about 60,000 km2 of pasture, in addition to the livestock development. The volume
of harvested water totaled about 2.6 millions m3. The projects of the authority
of the Jordan valley have resulted in the construction of Hafir with a total storage capacity
of 80,000 m3 of water.In Al-Mowaker projects, runoff water is controlled with earth dams
with a capacity of 115,000 m3, with the water being utilized for supplemental
irrigation.The area of the main basin is about 70 km2, with a project area of
0.2 km2. The water is used for irrigation of field crops, fruit trees and fodder shrubs.
Through the development project of the Al-Zarka river basin, with a project area of 150 km2,
the volume of harvested water reached about 150,000 m3/year (with a rainfall of 350 mm/year),
with the water being used for irrigation (olive, nuts, field crops). In fact, the range of these
technologies offers ideal solutions to supplying water resources at many locations.
Cisterns help secure water for areas that otherwise lack sufficient water resources, including
the southern region of Syria and the steppe region.Small dams help secure drinking and irrigation
water for rural and steppe communities. They also contribute to agricultural expansion and economic
development via construction of factories or electric power generation, as well as increased
tourist activity. The agricultural catchment ponds in Palestine also have contributed to securing
a water supply, and have proved to be a substitute for wells during the dry season. In fact,
the water they supply is sufficient to meet the water requirements that otherwise would have had
to be contributed from groundwater sources during the period between February to July.
This means that water is stored in these ponds for a period of five months.The volume of evaporation
losses was estimated to total about 17% of the total volume of stored water.
Suitability
Runoff water harvesting technologies are suitable for areas lacking a sustainable surface or
sub-surface water supply for meeting different development activities, or which
are subject to large changes in rainfall rates. In addition, the long dry season that limit
the ability ensure drinking and irrigation water throughout the year mandate the utilization of
different technologies for rainwater storage, to be used when necessary. Desert regions characterized
by intense rainstorms and high evaporation losses impose a necessity to construct some
water structures for storing this water either on the land surface or underground.Surface water
storage is implemented via spreading the water on the largest possible pasture areas, or
storing it behind dams to be used irrigating forage crops. In fact, the climate prevailing
in the West Asia region requires that its countries achieve the optimum use of all water
resources by all possible means.
The agricultural catchment pond technology is particularly suited for regions with
high rainfall rates, and for productive water sources that exceed water requirements in some seasons
and are insufficient in other seasons. It also is suitable for areas in which several farms utilize
the same water resource.
Advantages
The advantages of this technology are as follows:
- The runoff water harvesting structures are relatively simple, uncomplicated engineering
structures, and can be used throughout the regions and communities, particularly the rural areas;
- They allow for securing a water supply to be used when needed, particularly during periods
of little or no rainfall, for supplemental irrigation and livestock watering;
- They do not require significant expertise for their implementation, and have both low
construction costs and simple maintenance requirements;
- They facilitate the utilization of floodwaters, rather than allowing them to be
wasted or lost via evaporation.They also contribute to development of vegetative cover and increases
in livestock;
- They provide green areas and recreational areas;
- Because they represent relatively stable water resources, they help alleviate some
social problems, especially unemployment in rural communities, as well as
contributing to social stability in rural communities;
- They indirectly help renew and improve natural recharge of groundwater aquifers,
thereby improving groundwater quality.
Disadvantages
The disadvantages of this technology are as follows:
- Small dams are subject to failure, and to filling with sediment (sometimes within one
year) due to severe rainstorms, thereby rendering them useless;
- The construction cost of small dams is high, relative to their economic feasibility.
Their maintenance costs also can be costly if the dam has a short lifetime due to sedimentation.
Large dams can be built to avoid the problem of sedimentation filling small dams. However,
the costs of large dams is very high, relative to their economic feasibility;
- Water surfaces and cisterns provide a suitable environment for spreading water diseases
(e.g., Bilharzia, malaria), especially if the necessary steps to protect them from contamination
are not taken;
- Some water surfaces result in increased evaporation, thereby accelerating water
losses without achieving the desired water supply goals;
- Some water storage structures experience leakage problems, particularly sites with
heterogenous soils, or sites at which the necessary steps to increase soil
impermeability during the construction phase have not been taken;
- Water disinfection and filtration are required prior to its use. Further, the water quality
may vary as a function of rainfall severity and from transported sediments and suspended
materials;
- Some lower areas of river valleys may be deprived of needed water resources because
of the improper distribution of the stored water.
Cultural Acceptance
All types of runoff water harvesting technologies are considered acceptable to the local
populations.Because they facilitate the expansion of agricultural activities and livestock breeding,
they contribute to increasing the income levels of the settlement populations. They also do not
require high technical expertise for their operation or maintenance.
Further Development of the Technology
Further research was conducted to develop and make these technologies more effective.
Various objectives of these research projects include the following:
- Optimizing the efficiency of water-feeding methods through increasing runoff water volumes
by different measures within the watershed basin;
- In-depth studies on the relationship between rainfall volumes and runoff flows, in order
to make accurate calculations of the runoff flow. This is done by constructing and installing
climatic and hydrologic stations;
- Proper selection of sites for cisterns and dams, and proper design of water inlet and
distribution networks for irrigation and/or domestic purposes, as well as carrying out necessary
procedures for protecting water surfaces and tanks from contamination;
- Expanding the utilization of modern irrigation technologies, rather than conventional
irrigation, in using harvested water;
- Reducing water losses, particularly via evaporation, using plastic covers, as well as
reducing leakage from the tank bottom with the use of linings.
Information Sources
Contacts
Aly Al-Quesy
Head, Research and Water Studies Depatment
Irrigation and Water Use Directorate
Ministry of Agriculture and Land Reclamation
Damascus, Syria
Tel: 5323098
Fax: 5323098
Abdel-Naby Fardous
Deputy General Director
National Center of Agricultural Research and Technology Transfer
P.O. Box: 639 Al-Baqa’ah- Amman, Jordan
Tel: 725411
Fax: 726099
Abdel-Aziz Al-Terbaq
King Saud’s University
P.O. Box: 800-Riyadh 11421, Saudi Arabia
Fax: 4674254,
Abdel-Rahman Al-Tamimy
Palestine Consultancy Group
Jerusalem, Palestine
George Somy
Director of Irrigation and Water Use
Ministry of Agriculture and Land Reclamation
P.O. Box: 31267
Damascus, Syria
Tel: 5323098
Fax: 5323098
Mohammed Said Al-Hamidy
General Director of Palestinian Environment Authority
Ram Allah, Palestine
Mohammed Abu-Haqt
Faculty of Letters/Geographic Division
Al-Najah National University
P.O. Box: 7
Nablus, Palestine
Marawan Haddad
Director of Water and Environmental Studies
Najah National Univeristy
P.O. Box: 7
Nablus, Palestine
Tel: 383124
Fax: 387982
Noaman Farid
Faculty of Agriculture
Al-Najah National University
P.O. Box: 7
Nablus, Palestine
Palestinian Ministry of Agriculture
National Palestinian Authority
Ram Allah, Palestine.
References
Abdel-Karim Al-Fasil and Abbad Mohamed Al-a’nsy. 1999. Yemen Country Report,
Project for the preparation of the Source Book for Alternative Technologies for
Freshwater Augmentation in the West Asia Region. Internal Technical Report, ACSAD, Damascus.
Abd-Razzaq and Abu Saleh. 1991. Irrigation ponds in Ghore region. Technical report, Rural
Research Center, Nablus, An-Najah University.
ACSAD. 1983. Analysis and development of the Arab water technologies. Country reports.
ACSAD and UNESCO. 1985. Main regional project for the optimum use and maintenance of
water resources in rural areas in the Arab countries, concentrating on the
conventional water systems.ACSAD,
Damascus, Syria.370 p.
ACSAD-IFAD. 1997. Scientific work circular on rainwater harvesting and supplemental
irrigation for arid and semi-arid regions in the Arab World. ACSAD, Damascus, Syria.
FAO. 1989. Guidelines for designing and evaluating surface irrigation system. 45,137 p.
FAO. 1991. Water harvesting - Annual for the design and construction of water
harvesting schemes for plant production. AGL/MISC/17/91.
FAO. 1994. Water harvesting for improved agricultural production. Proceedings, FAO Expert
Consultation, November, 1993, Cairo, Egypt.424 p.
Haddad, M. 1994. A survey of rainwater harvesting in Palestine. Technical report, Palestine
Consultancy Group (East Jerusalem) and IDRC-Canada and University of Ottawa.
Haddad, M. 1999. Palestine Country Report, Project for the preparation of the Source Book
for Alternative Technologies for Freshwater Augmentation in the West Asia Region.Internal
Technical Report, ACSAD, Damascus.
ICARD. 1987. Supplemental irrigation in the Near East and North Africa. In:
Perriet and Salikini (eds), Workshop Proceedings, Regional Consultation
on Supplemental Irrigation, ICARDA and FAO, December 1987, Rabat, Morocco,
Kluwer Academic Publishers.911 p.
Majed A. 1994. Information on rain catchment cisterns in Hebron district. Personal communication,
University Graduate Union, Hebron.
Salem Abdullah Baqhezel, Ibrahim Ahmad Said and Mohamed Salem ben-Gouth.1996. Documentary study
on examples of conventional irrigation systems and water harvesting methods in Hadramout and
Shbouh governorates.Environmental Protection Council, Aden, Ministry Cabinet.
|