Newsletter and Technical Publications
<International Source Book On Environmentally Sound Technologies
for Wastewater and Stormwater Management>
3.3 Treatment (Topic c)
3.3.1 Small-scale treatment (household on-site treatment)
The minimum facilities required for most of the households in the Asia
Pacific developing countries are latrines and suitable on-site or other means of
satisfactory disposal of waste from these households.
Most households use so called "unsealed" septic tanks. This is a
two chamber tank with a volume of 2-4 m3 with open bottom and without overflow
pipe. In areas where the ground is too impermeable to allow infiltration, or the
groundwater level is too close to the ground surface, there is an overflow pipe
that allows the wastewater to flow into the street drains, or elsewhere. The
share of households that use on-site disposal in South Vietnam is two to three
times as high as in North Vietnam, which underscores the fact the sanitary
conditions are better in urban areas in the South than in the North.
It is a common misconception of public officials that septic tanks provide
satisfactory sewage treatment and that STE (Septic Tank Effluent) is a
satisfactory end product. Septic tanks are meant as pre-treatment for the
removal of suspended solids prior to disposal by means of a sub-surface leaching
field. Septic tanks remove about 60% of the suspended solids and 30% of the BOD
of raw sewage. The effluent still contains most of the organic pollutants and
pathogens. The suspended solids that settle in septic tanks are partially
stabilised by anaerobic digestion. Biological activities reduce the mass of
sewage solids in the tank; however, the septic tank still accumulates solids
over time. Typically, in Asia septic tanks are relatively small and should be
cleaned every two to three years. If not, solids will pass through the septic
tank and into drainage canals.
An estimated 70% of households in developing countries, which have flush
toilets, also have septic tanks. Most of these tanks are in very poor condition
due to insufficient maintenance. In some cases, solids pass through the septic
tank and into the drainage system. In contrast, a fairly large number of
households do not have septic tanks, probably in the range of 10%. There are
some houses which still use the double vault and bucket latrines. The number of
households that are without toilet facilities or rely on such devises as
overhang toilets, remains at 20%. This means that the equivalent of primary
treatment is provided to only 40-50% of the domestic wastewater flow.
Among Jakarta’s 1.4 million poor people, the greatest environmental threat
still occurs at the household and neighbourhood level. One recent survey found
that in the poorest socio-economic quartile, 31% of the households have neither
a piped water connection nor neighbourhood access to a private well, compared
with 12% for the city as a whole. In addition, the poorest households were less
likely to have neighbourhood waste collection, more likely to share toilets and
to have problems with flies both near toilets and in food-handing areas.
Table 3.7 shows toilet types in the surveyed cities of Vietnam as a
percentage of households.
Table 3.7: Toilet types in surveyed cities in Vietnam (%
households)
| City |
Class |
Region |
Flush or pour flush latrines |
Double vault latrines |
Bucket latrines |
No individual toilets |
| Ha noi |
I |
North |
48 |
18 |
16 |
18 |
| Hai phong |
II |
North |
27 |
0 |
23 |
50 |
| Thai nguyen |
III |
North |
45 |
0 |
24 |
31 |
| Hai duong |
III |
North |
55 |
33 |
0 |
12 |
| Bac giang |
III |
North |
0 |
0 |
100 |
0 |
| HCMC |
I |
South |
91 |
0 |
0 |
5 |
| Da nang |
II |
South |
83 |
4 |
0 |
13 |
| Hue |
II |
South |
63 |
1 |
0 |
36 |
| Can tho |
II |
South |
91 |
0 |
0 |
9 |
| Phan thiet |
II |
South |
36 |
0 |
0 |
64 |
| Nha tranh |
III |
South |
82 |
0 |
0 |
18 |
| Source: Vietnam National Urban Wastewater
collection and Sanitation Strategy Nov. 1995. |
In developing countries only 8% of urban low-income dwellers have a house
sewer connection, compared with 62% of the urban high-income dwellers.
Low-income families often share latrines with 100 or more other community
members, and long lines or overflowing tanks deter residents from using them at
all.
For household wastewater, the available technologies fall into on-site and
off-site categories, with a large number of potential technologies in both
categories. The three most relevant on-site technologies for urban conditions in
the developing countries are summarised below:
The most relevant on-site technologies
- Ventilated improved pit latrine (no water needed)
- Pour flush latrine or flush toilet with septic tank (large capacity septic
tanks are required to include both sullage water and excreta)
- Soakaways or soakage pits for septic tank effluent, where soil
permeability is reasonable and where distance to ground water table is
tolerable.
- Communal or shared facilities for squatter areas (although case-by-case
solution will be needed in some locations, for example over waterways)
The most common off-site technologies
- Small-bore sewer (accept septic tank effluent)
- Septage (septic tank sludge, scum and liquid) cartage and treatment in
multi-stage lagoon
- Simplified or condominial (low cost) local sewers
- Dry-weather-flow interceptors (to remove septic tank overflow from open
drains)
- Conventional trunk sewers and pumping stations
- Treatment of collected or intercepted wastewater by low-cost means,
including where appropriate, multi-stage lagoon and/or aquatic plant
systems.
- Basic primary treatment and disposal through marine outfalls with
diffusers or on land
Criteria for technology selection include
- Effectiveness and operability
- Affordability and cost recovery possibility
- Acceptability to the user
- Availability of trained personnel for operation and maintenance
- Sustainability
In most of the developed countries, 100% of households have flush toilets.
These systems function well and are adequately operated and maintained.
|