Newsletter and Technical Publications
<International Source Book On Environmentally Sound Technologies
for Wastewater and Stormwater Management>
8.2 Environmental considerations
Achievement of protection of environmental quality is implicitly assumed when
we consider technologies for wastewater and stormwater management. These
considerations are (i) the need to protect the environment and (ii) the
imperative of recycling/reusing the water and nutrients in the water. The first
factor is usually taken into account by making sure that standards for discharge
of wastewater are met. Standards alone should not be relied upon, because it is
the capacity of the environment to assimilate the wastes that should not be
exceeded. Each local environment has its own capacity depending amongst others
on the natural throughflow of water, climatic, vegetation and soil conditions.
Reuse of the water and nutrients conserve these resources in a world where
water will in the future be a precious resource for growing food and maintain
ecosystems for the world’s increasing population and standard of living. Reuse
of water can in fact fulfil the objective of protecting the environment, because
reuse has standards which have to be met prior to the water being able to be
reused. A corollary to the above two factors is the need to exclude toxic and
hazardous chemicals from being mixed and discharged with human excreta.
Treatment, reuse or disposal of wastewater and stormwater containing toxic and
hazardous chemicals will be considerably more difficult than treating the toxic
and hazardous wastes separately.
Table 2.5: Technologies for wastewater and stormwater management (with
relative costs, environmental impact and maintenance requirement)
| Wastewater management technologies |
|
| Technology |
Capital cost |
Operation &
maintenance cost |
Environmental impact |
|
| On-site technology |
|
|
|
| Pit latrine |
Low |
Low |
Pollution of groundwater |
| Composting toilet |
Low |
Low |
Reuse of nutrients |
| Pour flush toilet |
Low |
Low |
Pollution of groundwater |
| Improved on site treatment unit |
Medium to high |
Low to medium |
Reuse of water and nutrients |
Off-site technology
Collection technology |
|
|
|
| Conventional sewerage |
High |
High |
Dependent on treatment |
| Simplified sewerage |
Medium to high |
Medium |
Dependent on treatment |
| Settled sewerage |
Medium |
Low |
Dependent on treatment |
| |
|
|
|
| Treatment technology |
|
|
|
| Activated sludge |
High |
High |
Nutrients may need removal |
| Trickling filtration |
Medium |
Medium |
Nutrients may need removal |
| Lagoons |
Low to medium
(dependent on cost of land) |
Low |
Nutrients may need removal; aquaculture
can be incorporated |
| Land-based treatment |
Low to medium
(dependent on cost of land) |
Low to medium |
Reuse of water and nutrients |
| Constructed wetland |
Low to medium
(dependent on cost of land) |
Low |
Amenity value |
| Anaerobic treatment |
Medium |
Medium |
Produces biogas; further aerobic
treatment needed |
|
| Stormwater management technologies* |
|
| Technology |
Source control |
Site control |
Regional control |
|
| Filter strips and swales |
O |
|
|
| Filter drains and permeable surfaces |
O |
|
|
| Infiltration devices |
|
O |
|
| Basins and ponds |
|
|
O |
|
| *Cost increases from source control
to regional control technology. |
Conservation of resources needs to consider water conservation at the point
of its use. Less water used means less wastewater produced. The hierarchy of
waste management discussed in Section 1 (4) emphasises this point, and should be
seriously considered in achieving sound technology practice.
|