|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Technical Workbook on Environmental Management Tools for
Decision Analysis>

Environmental Risk Assessment (EnRA)
Marlito L. Cardenas, Ph.d.
ABSTRACT
Risk is broadly defined as the likelihood that a harmful consequence will
occur as the result of an action or condition. It involves the combined evaluation
of hazards and exposure. Environmental risk assessment (EnRA) deals with the interactions
of agents or hazards, humans and ecological resources. It describes human populations,
ecological resources and agents, analyzes agents and exposure potential, characterizes
the potential for adverse effects, defines uncertainties, generates options to
deal with the risks, and communicates information about the risks to humans and
ecosystems. EnRA has two components: Human Health Risk Assessment (HHRA) and Ecological
Risk Assessment (EcoRA).
EnRA provides a technical basis for evaluating current environmental conditions
and forecasting future conditions under selected scenarios. EnRA is a welcome
addition to the tools that an environmental planner and a manager can use to facilitate
decision making by various stakeholders. Stakeholder involvement is now an accepted
and valued practice in modern environmental planning and management, including
EnRA, EIA and urban environmental management. Risk assessors should not only be
talking risk issues with risk managers, owners or investors of development projects
but also with the affected residents and sociopolitical advocates.
EnRA is a process that incorporates technical information and societal values
in arriving at risk management options. At its best practice, EnRA is an iteration
of scoping, screening and final tiers. Each tier progresses with increasing data
requirements and can be concluded at any stage if the management decisions are
already clear. The stages of doing an EnRA include: Hazard Identification and
Problem Formulation, Analysis, and Risk Characterization. The main outputs are
the risk management and communication plans.
Properly used, EnRA will take its place in attaining sustainable development
goals of industrialized and developing countries.
INTRODUCTION
The use of EnRA in urban and regional environmental planning and management
is fast becoming a standard practice - either as a stand alone or as a
complement to an environmental impact assessment (EIA). Its value lies in
identifying potential environmental resources for development and allowing
decision-makers to select management options with least negative effects. It
does so by evaluating both the benefits and consequences of development planning
options, and thus minimizing unwanted or unexpected consequences - in the
near-term and long-term (See Figure 1).
<figure 1>
Importance of risk assessment in urban environmental management

How Enra FITS Within The Decision-Making Loop
EnRA is a systematic and iterative process that can be employed at various
tiers of decision-making, whether it is policy, program, project or activity. At
the strategic level, EnRA may be employed at early stages of decision-making to
include readily available scientific and other information (e.g. political,
cultural, economic, legal, etc.) relevant to the strategy or policy initiative
at hand.
During the feasibility study phase, EnRA helps to define and evaluate
critical environmental parameters that will bear upon the decision whether to
proceed, how to proceed, and what to consider in the design and site selection
process.
These environmental risk factors will thus become performance indicators in
the commercial process and integrated as provisions in tender and contract
documents.
Key EnRA products are risk management and communication plans. These can
prove useful for assuring the success and sustainability of a development
policy, plan, program or project initiative. Periodic risk monitoring,
re-assessment and adjustment during operations become a vital part of the due
diligence practice of the organization concerned. The same due diligence is
critically needed during the decommissioning, abandonment, rehabilitation and
re-use phase of the development initiative.
|