|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Planning and Management of Lakes and Reservoirs:
An Integrated Approach to Eutrophication
Abridged Version- A Student's Guide>
Lessons Learned from Lake Chivero
Watershed dynamics
The changes in the watershed of Lake Chivero showed that watersheds can
change rapidly. Population increases, increased livestock on communal lands,
urban drift led to rapidly expanding urban populations, and intensified urban
cultivation due to increasing urban poverty all added to nutrient loads in the
lake. With all the best intentions, traditionally trained sanitary engineers
were not adequately equipped to deal with rapidly changing environmental issues.
Lake models generally assume a semi-equilibrium state, i.e., a more or less
fixed nutrient loading as a base line. However, this case study shows that
nutrient loading rates can change rapidly, and water quality managers should be
able to respond accordingly.
Multiple nutrient sources
Sanitary engineers design operational wastewater treatment works to cope with
expected deliveries from the sewage transport system. They assume that the most
important source of nutrients to receiving waters is the sewage reticulation,
and that if sewage is adequately treated, eutrophication problems would not
occur. As a result, the Harare Municipality invested heavily in sophisticated
sewage treatment works. However, the Lake Chivero case shows that nutrients can
arise from multiple sources, such as communal land farms, inadequately serviced
peri-urban areas, street runoff and badly sited waste dumps. Water quality
managers in developing countries must be alert and imaginative to deal with
multiple causes of eutrophication.
Public involvement
The Lake Chivero case also shows that the typical public servant tends to be
a lone bureaucrat quietly working on his assignments, and thus missing the
potential power of public participation. The majority of Harare dwellers are
unaware of the problems faced by the Municipality to provide them with clean
water, and are therefore not conditioned to taking remedial measures themselves.
However, for a eutrophication management strategy to be effective, there must be
participatory governance.
|