|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Planning and Management of Lakes and Reservoirs:
An Integrated Approach to Eutrophication
Abridged Version- A Student's Guide>
Public Participation
Decision-making process with public participation
To achieve the objectives of eutrophication control, public participation
throughout the period of decision-making is required. Public participation means
involving, informing, and consulting the public in planning, management, and
other decision-making activities that can be considered part of the political
process. Active public involvement in the decision-making process is one of the
strongest ways to obtain public and political support for the implementation of
environmental programs. In addition, planning and implementation is facilitated
if the public has direct involvement in the planning and decision-making
process.
Decision-makers should consider environmental education and community
participation as a priority in their national and local environmental policies.
It is crucial for effective public participation that communities and
environmental groups be aware of national and local priorities for development.
It is often easier for people to accept policies, even difficult or
controversial ones, when the importance and nature of the problem is properly
presented to them.
Specific objectives for public participation in decision-making for control
of eutrophication in lakes and reservoirs are as follows:
- Obtaining public acceptance for the principal goal of eutrophication
control.
- Obtaining public acceptance of remedies prepared by expert panels to
eliminate water pollution sources.
- Ensuring public control of implementation of remedies for protection of
water in lakes and reservoirs.
- Obtaining public involvement in monitoring of water resources.
- Reinforcing the position of the local government as a public entity
responsible for environmental quality.
The essential stages of the process are identification of particular
stakeholders concerned with the problem and selection of persons who will
represent those groups, selection and organization of public involvement, and
stimulation and integration of stakeholders.
Identification of stakeholders and methods for screening
Planning contacts with the public and public involvement activities for
protection of lakes and reservoirs requires the identification of stakeholders.
Careful selection of participants in the social dialogue is essential for
effective public participation in the decision-making processes.
The selection of stakeholders is based on the identification of interests and
level of public awareness of the aquatic environment. In some cases, the
stakeholders include local, national, or even international communities.
Usually, individual users of the environment have different, often conflicting
interests.
The manner in which particular stakeholders express their interests may vary
significantly. Interests may vary from personal ones with strong emotional
intensity to the public ones, represented by local authorities. Perceptions are
often connected with myths extant in a community.
The identification of stakeholders in a given community can be carried out by
screening existing organizations on the basis of published materials, direct
contact with organizations, and by using the experience and knowledge of local
communities and administrative authorities. A key way to identify stakeholders
is to approach water resource users: (1) Groups connected with fisheries, whose
existence depends on the quality of surface waters. (2) Groups connected with
urban settlements because households are one of the major sources of the
discharge of nutrients causing the eutrophication of surface waters. (3) Groups
connected with industry because the industrial sector can be a significant water
consumer and a source of emission of pollutants. (4) Farmers are an important
group as the runoff of nutrients from agricultural land is often a major cause
of nutrient enrichment of rivers and lakes. (5) Institutions indirectly or
directly involved in water resource management including local governments,
regional water authorities, businesses, and local and regional financial
institutions. Other stakeholders include the scientific community, naturalists,
and enthusiasts engaged in environmental protection.
When selecting the stakeholders, attention should be paid to those social
groups that influence social acceptance of aquatic environmental protection.
These groups can be identified through visits, surveys and discussion within
communities concerned with water resource management. Women, the young, and
representatives of the media can be counted in such groups.
Community representatives
Personal characteristics of representatives, their skills, their position in
a given community, and their connections with other groups of stakeholders are
important in the selection of participants. Any group of people has its leaders,
i.e., persons who are distinguished by their knowledge, experience and social
activity, and who have the respect of a given group. Such persons will best
represent the interests of particular groups.
It is desirable that the persons chosen to represent a given community or a
particular group of stakeholders have the following attributes: ability to
communicate well, ability to convey information and acquire knowledge, and
social commitment. The representatives should be moderate in their judgments and
open to the views of others. Attention should be paid to having balanced
representation of all groups who use the environment; omitting a group may
jeopardise the effectiveness of the communications.
Role of scientific groups and non-governmental organizations
Scientific groups and non-governmental organizations play a major role in the
public participation process. Scientists are among the first to discover
evidence of significant environmental risks and changes resulting from human
activities. However, this group seldom has taken a proactive approach to
solutions. It is recognized increasingly that interactions among scientists,
citizens' groups, non-governmental organizations, and the media create an
increasing public awareness of environmental issues. This, in turn, creates
public pressure that stimulates the decision-makers to act.
Non-governmental organizations have a special role in the integration of
communities. As independent entities, they constitute an important element in
public dialogue. They are usually regional organizations, experienced in public
environmental education, particularly in conducting educational campaigns,
organization of education for children, and public involvement in
decision-making processes. Non-governmental organizations often include
practitioners who can plan and conduct public dialogue. Through their contacts
with international organizations, they can also be useful in finding financial
support.
|