|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Planning and Management of Lakes and Reservoirs:
An Integrated Approach to Eutrophication
Abridged Version- A Student's Guide>
Wastewater Treatment Systems
As wastewater treatment is often costly (Table 1), the maximum allowable
concentrations should not be set significantly lower than those that the
ecosystem can tolerate without adverse impacts. The costs in Table 1 are valid
for treatment of 2000m3 per day, i.e., municipal wastewater for about 10,000
inhabitants. Costs per 100m3 for smaller and larger communities will vary
somewhat.
Waste Stabilization Ponds (WSPs)
Traditionally, waste stabilization ponds are built as flow-through systems
with the following processes being utilized in the pond system: settling (mainly
in the first ponds), anaerobic decomposition of organic matter (mainly in the
first ponds), aerobic decomposition of organic matter (mainly in the last ponds,
where algae are present and produce oxygen), uptake of phosphorus and nitrogen
by algae (maturation ponds), evaporation of ammonia (mainly where pH is high,
i.e., in the last ponds), settling of algae, and denitrification (in the
anaerobic zones). High removal efficiencies of biological oxygen demand over
five days (BOD5), of chemical oxygen demand (COD), of microorganisms, of
nitrogen, and of phosphorus may be obtained provided that the guidelines for
design and maintenance are followed.
Removal of phosphorus by WSPs can be in the range of 20 to 50% but depends on
removal of algae from the effluent. Enhanced removal of phosphorus, which is
often required for the discharge of wastewater to lakes and reservoirs, can be
achieved by addition of precipitants such as calcium compounds and clay
minerals, which often have local sources.
Constructed Wetlands
The transition zones between lakes and terrestrial ecosystems are crucial for
protection of lakes against anthropogenic impacts. Transition zones prevent, to
a certain extent, entry of undesirable substances into lakes, and, therefore,
should be preserved. Hence, construction should not be permitted in a zone 50 to
100 m from shorelines.
Non-point or diffuse pollutants from the environment flows toward lakes, but
the transition zone is able to transform or adsorb the pollutants. The most
important processes occurring in the transition zone are as follows:
- Nitrate is denitrified by the anaerobic conditions.
- Clay minerals adsorb ammonium.
- Organic matter adsorbs phosphorus compounds
- Biodegradable organic matter is decomposed aerobically or anaerobically by
microorganisms.
- Macrophytes store nutrients.
- Soils with a high calcium, magnesium, aluminum or iron content can adsorb
phosphorus.
- Suspended matter is removed along with associated nitrogen and phosphorus.
The denitrification potential of wetlands is often high. As much as 2,000 to
3,000 kg of nitrogen in nitrate can be denitrified per hectare of wetlands per
year. In addition, denitrification is accompanied by oxidation of organic
matter. However, phosphorus, bound in organic matter or adsorbed to the organic
matter, may be released.
The siting of artificial wetlands must be carefully planned because their
effects are dependent on the hydrology and on the landscape pattern. Non-fertile
land of moderate cost should be used. Constructed wetlands can be either surface
or subsurface wetlands. Subsurface wetlands are based on flow of water through
the soil, and oxygen is provided for biological decomposition via the root
network. Subsurface wetlands are usually of higher efficiency than surface
wetlands but require more maintenance to avoid clogging. When wetlands with open
water are used, mosquitoes should be controlled, for instance, by stocking of
insectivorous fish. Harvest of wetland plants will increase the efficiency of
nitrogen and phosphorus removal. The harvested plants can be used to feed
domestic animals, to produce methane or be composted.
The combination of WSPs and constructed or reclaimed wetlands are attractive
for the following reasons:
- Wetlands offer a significant reduction of suspended matter from WSP pond
effluents.
- Wetlands buffer the pH of the effluent from WSPs.
- Effluents from WSPs often need a polishing step as a post treatment.
Wetlands offer a cost-moderate solution.
Mechanical-Biological Treatment Methods
Mechanical-biological treatment is widely used in industrialized countries
and in developing countries where the cost of land is high (see the decision
tree in Figure 1). Treatment costs of US$28-48/100m3 are about 2-3 times the
cost of treatment based on the combination WSPs and constructed wetlands.
However, where the cost of land is high and proper maintenance of the facilities
is maintained, mechanical-biological treatment could be preferable.
Mechanical treatment combines the use of a sieve, a grid chamber (with a
retention time about 20 minutes during which sand settles and grease is removed)
and a sedimentation chamber where finer particles are removed during a retention
of 2-6 hours. Biological treatment follows mechanical treatment and uses air to
accelerate the decomposition of organic matter. Two alternative processes are an
activated sludge treatment or a trickling filter. The trickling filter employs
uptake of air from the atmosphere by recycling the water over a large surface,
while activated sludge uses input of air from an aerator or compressor. A
retention time of 2-6 hours is usually required to obtain 85-95% removal of
BOD5. The biological step is followed by a secondary sedimentation where
suspended matter resulting from the biological activity is removed. The sludge
is partly recycled to ensure a high concentration of active microorganisms in
the biological step. The sludge can be used to produce methane, and the
stabilized sludge can be applied as soil conditioner, provided that it does not
have too high a concentration of toxic substances (for further details see
chapter 6 in IETC's Technical Information Series number 11).
A mechanical-biological treatment plant can be modified and expanded to
include removal of phosphorus and nitrogen. By addition of a precipitant in the
grid chamber, it is possible to achieve a 75-95% removal of phosphorus during
the primary sedimentation. Since phosphorus will be present in the stabilized
sludge, it improves the quality of the sludge as a soil conditioner. Nitrogen
removal by nitrification and denitrification is possible by increasing the
retention time considerably in the biological step and by switching between
aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Nitrification requires an increased recycling
of sludge, as the sludge age has to be increased to about ten days. These
modifications lead to an increase in treatment costs by a factor of 2-3 (see
Table 1).

Figure 1. Decision tree for the selection of wastewater treatment
methods to be used for medium and large-scale facilities.

Figure 2. Decision tree for the selection of wastewater treatment
methods
|