Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Proceedings of the International Symposium on Efficient Water Use in Urban
Areas
- Innovative Ways of Finding Water for Cities ->
WATER DEMAND MANAGEMENT AND THE URBAN POOR
Madeleen Wegelin-Schuringa
IRC International Water and Sanitation Centre
1. Introduction
The provision of adequate water supply and sanitation to the rapidly growing
urban populations is increasingly becoming a problem for governments throughout
the world. The continuing expansion of the numbers of people in cities who need
water and sanitation services and who cannot readily get these services by self
provision, form a continuous pressure to either invest in additional production
capacity or to stretch the available supplies to serve more people. At the same
time, industrial activity also demands the expansion of urban water supply
services. The water resources are threatened not only by this rapidly increasing
demand but also through diminishing quality caused by pollution and saline
intrusion as well as reducing quantity caused by overexploitation and denuding
of water catchment areas. Finally, water demand for agricultural use in most
places is also growing and competing with water availability for urban use.
The predominant approach towards meeting these increasing water demands has
been towards supply augmentation schemes. But, the cost of developing new
sources or expanding existing sources is getting higher and higher as the most
accessible water resources have already been tapped. The real cost of water per
cubic meter in second and third generation projects in some cities have doubled
between a first and the second project and then doubled again between the second
and third (Bhatia and Falkenmark, 1993). At the same time, governments are
becoming reluctant to pay the rising investment costs as long as utilities are
unable to meet these cost from user charges.
It has been demonstrated in many countries that saving water rather than the
development of new sources is often the best ‘next’ source of water, both
from an economic and from an environmental point of view. Water demand
management therefore is seen as the preferred alternative to meet increasing
water demand and can be defined as a strategy to improve efficiency and
sustainable use of water resources taking into account economic, social and
environmental considerations.
The main objective of water demand management is to contribute to more
efficient and equitable provision of water and sanitation services and to reach
this objective a number of instruments have been developed. These instruments
are interdependent and mutually reinforcing and the most optimal way they are
applied will depend on the prevailing local conditions and are the topic of a
number of presentations in this symposium.
With regard to the domestic consumer, water demand management measures can be
divided in:
1. Water conservation measures:
- Leakage detection
- Reduction of illegal connections
- In-house retrofitting
- Out-of-house water saving measures
2. Water pricing measures:
- Water metering
- Tariff structures
3. Information and educational measures:
- Awareness raising
- Public involvement
- In-school education
4. Legal measures
- Rules and regulations that form the basis of WDM policy
- Regulations on resale of water
In all cities, a distinction can be made between different income groups
(high, middle and low), between the different types of urban areas they live in
and hence between the different water demand management measures which are
applicable. The authorities responsible for water supply mainly provide
subsidized services to high and middle income areas and the inequality of access
to basic services is most severely felt in low-income urban areas, where up to
60% of the urban populations are living. The focus of this paper is especially
on the applicability of WDM strategies for the urban poor and on approaches to
ensure that the WDM savings are indeed also used for a more equitable provision
of the water supply. The water quality aspects of WDM, including monitoring of
quality, are outside the scope of this paper.
2. Current provision patterns in cities in developing countries
Urban water supply coverage has actually decreased between 1990 and 1994 in
parts of the developing world, an indication of urban growth but also of
deterioration of existing systems.
|
Table 1: Urban water supply coverage in 1990 and 1994
|
|
AREA
|
1990
|
1994
|
|
Latin America
|
90%
|
88%
|
|
Asia and the Pacific
|
83%
|
84%
|
|
West Asia
|
87%
|
98%
|
|
Africa
|
67%
|
64%
|
| Source: Water Supply and Sanitation Sector
Monitoring Report, WHO, WSSCC and Unicef, 1996 |
This coverage includes house connections and access to public standpost,
managed by the water utility. The overview below gives some more insight in the
division between the two types of supply. The people who are not covered by the
public network, are dependent on private wells or boreholes, rivers or springs,
vendors or neighbours.
|
Table 2: Percentage of urban population connected to
city network or dependent on communal water points
|
|
City
|
Houseconnection
|
Public tap
|
|
Jakarta (1991)
|
30%
|
30%
|
|
Delhi (1992)
|
53%
|
37%
|
|
Phnom Penh (1992)
|
70%
|
-
|
|
Casablanca (1997)
|
80%
|
17%
|
|
Ouagadougou (1994)
|
38%
|
17%
|
|
Conakry (1989)
|
20%
|
5%
|
|
Buenos Aires (1993)
|
80%
|
-
|
| Source: Lyonnaise des Eaux, 1998 |
These percentages do not reflect the intra urban differences and do not show
the desperate water situation existing in many low-income urban areas. For
Jakarta, for instance, the Northern sector, which is the most disadvantaged
district in terms of water supplies, the coverage was only 13% with private
connection and 27% with public standpost, the remainder being dependent on water
vendors and neighbourhood resale. This neighbourhood resale can address a very
large percentage of water demand, for instance in Conakry, 35% of the residents
obtain water from such source. Actual access to safe drinking water is likely to
be lower than is reflected by the above percentages due to intermittent supply.
Many residents augment the water provided by the utility with water from other
sources. In general, access to utility provided water supply is dependent on
location and income and different for different segments of society:
|