Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Proceedings of the International Symposium on Efficient Water Use in Urban
Areas
- Innovative Ways of Finding Water for Cities ->
Session 3: Water Reuse for Non-potable
Applications
WASTEWATER REUSE FOR NON-POTABLE APPLICATIONS: AN INTRODUCTION
Takashi Asano, Ph.D., P.E. Department of Civil and
Environmental Engineering University of California at Davis Davis,
CA 95616-2311, U.S.A.
ABSTRACT
The role of wastewater reclamation and reuse in the context of efficient
water use in urban areas is reviewed. Over the past few decades, the use
of water increased rapidly and significantly. Frequent droughts,
increasing water development costs, institutional and environmental
concerns, and a growing conservation philosophy are key factors accounting
for current surge of interest in wastewater reclamation and reuse
throughout the world. Reclaimed water is, after all, a water resource
existing right at the doorstep of the urban environment where water
resources are needed most and priced the highest. Furthermore, reclaimed
water provides a reliable source of water even in drought years because
the generation of urban wastewater is affected little by drought. In this
paper, fundamental concepts of wastewater reclamation and reuse are
reviewed which include applicable wastewater treatment processes and
operations, categories of water reuse, emphasizing the role of water
reclamation and reuse in the context of more sustainable water resources
development.
In every wastewater reclamation and reuse operation, however, there is
some risk of human exposure to infectious agents. Because of the public
health concerns, special attention is paid to wastewater treatment systems
that are capable of producing essentially pathogen-free effluent for
variety of beneficial uses. Finally, regulatory aspects of wastewater
reuse in developing countries are discussed.
KEYWORDS
Pathogens, planning, public health, water quality regulations, water
resources, wastewater reclamation and reuse, wastewater treatment.
INTRODUCTION
As the worldwide demand for water increases, wastewater reclamation and
reuse have become increasingly important in water resources management by
allowing a water supply agency to plan for increasing long-term water
supply reliability in agriculture, industry, and municipality. In
industrialized countries, there are growing problems of providing
dependable water supply, and municipal and industrial wastewater disposal.
In developing countries, particularly those in arid parts of the world,
there is a need to develop economically feasible new water supplies and
protect existing water sources from pollution. The water pollution control
efforts in many countries have made treated effluent available that may be
an economical augmentation to the existing water supply when compared to
the increasingly expensive and environmentally destructive new water
resources development. However, wastewater reuse is only one alternative
in planning to meet future water resources needs. Water conservation,
water recycling in industries, efficient management and use of existing
water supplies, and new water resources development based on
environmentally conscious watershed management are the examples of other
alternatives.
The advantages as well as motivating factors for wastewater reuse are
identified as follows:
- Water pollution abatement, not discharging into receiving waters
- Availability of highly treated effluents for various beneficial uses
enforced by increasingly stringent water pollution control requirements
- Providing long-term water supply reliability within the community by
substituting freshwater
- Water demand and drought management in overall water resources
planning
- Responsible public policy encouraging resources conservation
including water conservation and wastewater recycling and reuse
However, a common misconception in planning for wastewater reclamation
and reuse is that reclaimed wastewater represents a low-cost new water
supply. This assumption is generally true only when wastewater reclamation
facilities are conveniently located near large agricultural or industrial
users and when no additional treatment is required beyond the existing
water pollution control facilities from which reclaimed water is
delivered. The conveyance and distribution systems for reclaimed water
represent the principal cost of most proposed water reuse projects. Recent
experience in California indicates that approximately four million U.S.
dollars in capital cost are required for each one million m3 per year of
reclaimed water that made available for reuse. Assuming a facility life of
20 years and a nine percent interest rate, the amortized cost of this
reclaimed water is about $0.45/m3, excluding O & M costs.
Wastewater reclamation and reuse involves considerations of public
health and also requires close examinations of infrastructure and
facilities planning, wastewater treatment and plant siting, treatment
process reliability, economic and financial analyses, and water utility
management involving effective integration of domestic water supply and
reclaimed wastewater distribution. Whether wastewater reuse will be
appropriate in a community depends upon careful economic considerations,
potential uses for the reclaimed water, stringency in environmental
protection and waste discharge, and public policy wherein the desire to
conserve rather than develop new water resources with considerable
environmental impacts. Today, technically proven wastewater treatment or
purification processes exist to provide water of almost any quality
desired. Thus, wastewater reuse has a rightful place and an important role
in optimal planning and more efficient management and use of water
resources in many countries.
Wastewater reclamation is the treatment or processing of
wastewater to make it reusable, and water reuse is the use of
treated wastewater for a beneficial use such as agricultural irrigation
and industrial cooling. In addition, direct wastewater reuse
requires existence of pipes or other conveyance facilities for delivering
reclaimed water. Indirect reuse, through discharge of an effluent
to a receiving water for assimilation and withdrawals downstream, is
recognized to be important but does not constitute planned direct
water reuse. In contrast to direct water reuse, water
recycling normally involves only one use or user and the effluent from
the user is captured and redirected back into that use scheme. In this
context, water recycling is predominantly practiced in industry such as in
pulp and paper industry (Metcalf & Eddy, 1991).
WASTEWATER TREATMENT TECHNOLOGIES FOR WATER REUSE
In evaluating wastewater reclamation technologies, the overriding
considerations are the operational reliability of each wastewater
treatment process and operation, and the overall capability of complete
treatment system to provide a reclaimed water that meets established water
quality standards and/or criteria. As a result, additional treatment
processes and operations may be required in certain water reuse
applications for removal of chemical contaminants and removal or
inactivation of microbiological pathogens.
In conventional wastewater treatment, the general terms used to describe
different degrees of treatment, in order of increasing treatment level,
are preliminary, primary, secondary, and tertiary/advanced treatment. A
disinfection step for removal or inactivation of pathogenic organisms is
often the final treatment prior to storage and distribution for reuse.
Because of cost considerations, preliminary and primary treatment in
developing countries, and secondary treatments in industrialized countries
are generally considered as water pollution control requirements; the
additional treatment required for water reuse is normally designated as
tertiary or advanced wastewater treatment. The goal in designing a
wastewater reclamation and reuse system is to develop integrated
cost-effective process combinations that are capable of reliably meeting
the water quality objectives required for wastewater reuse.
Figure 1 shows a generalized view of wastewater treatment processes and
operations as well as effluent reuse schemes. Based on water quality
requirements, any effluent stream can be used as reclaimed water for
various beneficial uses. The range of applicable technologies may include:
1) septic tanks, lagoons, wetland, and natural treatment systems, 2)
secondary wastewater treatment systems, 3) advanced physical-chemical
treatment, 4) advanced biological treatment including biological nutrient
removal (BNR), 5) advanced oxidation processes, 6) membrane separation and
membrane bioreactors, 7) disinfection technologies, and 8) innovative
reactor designs such as sequencing batch reactors and advanced mixing
devices.
.gif)
(larger image)
Figure 1. Generalized wastewater treatment processes and operations, and
effluent reuse schemes (Adapted from Asano, Smith, and Tchobanoglous,
1985).
Advanced treatment plays a critical role in the effective treatment of
municipal and industrial wastewater to meet higher water quality
objectives for water reuse and to protect public health. Conventional and
advanced wastewater treatment consist of a combination of physical,
chemical, and biological processes and operations to remove settleable,
suspended, and dissolved solids, organic matter, metals, nutrients, and
pathogens from wastewater. Most of the current wastewater reclamation and
reuse technologies are essentially derived from those used in water and
wastewater treatment. However, opportunities for adopting technological
innovations are much greater for water reuse applications, because
reclaimed water will have an economic value as an alternative water
supply. Furthermore, contrary to the disposal of treated effluent, where
federal or national regulations are enforced by command and control
methods of water pollution control, water reclamation and reuse allow more
flexibility in water quality management, and consequently more
possibilities for adopting innovative technologies.
Table 1 shows a summary of major unit operations and processes used for
wastewater reclamation. At present, the dominant wastewater reuse
applications, worldwide, are irrigation of agricultural lands, parks and
golf courses. However, there has been considerable progress in reclaimed
water applications in the urban setting such as toilet flushing, cooling,
fire fighting, and stream flow augmentation. Furthermore, future use of
reclaimed water may involve a completely controlled "pipe-to-pipe"
system with an intermittent storage step, or it may include blending of
reclaimed water with non-reclaimed water, either directly in an engineered
system or indirectly through a surface water supply reservoir or a
groundwater recharge scheme.
|