|
C. Review and discussion of environmental
assessment techniques, with a focus on EnTA
John Hay presented an overview of environmental assessment techniques,
thereby providing a context for environmental technology assessment. He noted
that environmental assessments address three core values:
- environmental sustainability, by building in environmental safeguards;
- integrity, by having the assessments conform to agreed standards; and
- utility, by providing balanced and credible information for decision making.
Environmental assessments, including environmental technology assessment,
facilitate improved environmental outcomes by:
- recognising that the "environment" is wider than ecosystems and
living resources, for it includes economic, social, aesthetic and cultural
conditions and amenity values;
- adopting proactive management approaches that emphasise problem prevention
rather than problem correction;
- adopting an adaptive management approach due to uncertainties in initial
identification of potentially adverse environmental impacts;
- considering the wider technological system, rather than the technology
itself, in isolation; and
- identifying and assessing alternative technology options.
D. Economics of battery recycling
Ulrich Hoffman reviewed the likely environmental impact on different
economies arising from the economic effects of the Basel Ban Amendment. While
not yet in force, the Amendment is being imposed voluntarily by many countries,
including the Republic of the Philippines. The Amendment bans the export of
hazardous wastes, including lead acid batteries and lead wastes, from OECD
countries to non-OECD countries. Under prevailing conditions in the Philippines,
the Basel Ban Amendment effectively encourages the importation of primary lead
in order to bridge the domestic supply-demand gap because primary lead is nearly
as cheap as secondary lead. A comprehensive national strategy is therefore
required to reduce waste generation, enhance access to domestic sources of lead
scrap and make recycling environmentally sound and economically viable and
efficient.
He went on to identify the elements of a national strategy that included
optimizing collection, enhancing the environmental performance of the formal
sector, and the downsizing and integration of the informal sector into the
regulated sector. Packages of policy measures include those that involve
significant government intervention with respect to collection, research and
development for prolonged battery life, production of a low cost battery line
and facilitating the use of environmentally sound technologies. Another package
of policy measures would promote high capacity utilization of licensed recyclers
through supplementary regulation and public financial support for collection,
private sector investment in new technology and research and development for
prolonged battery life, public financial support for easing sales conditions of
an inexpensive battery line and allowing battery scrap imports by licensed
secondary recyclers. Major determining factors as to which policy measures
should be used are the international lead price and the foreign and domestic
supplies of used lead acid batteries.
E. Construction and design of the modern recyclable lead
acid battery
Brian Wilson described the make up and design of the modern recyclable lead
acid battery. The major components are the electrodes (typically pure lead oxide
and lead sulfate for the cathode, with the anode being a grid of metallic lead
alloy with various elemental additives that might include antimony, calcium,
arsenic, copper, tin and selenium), the electrolyte (dilute sulfuric acid), the
separators, lead terminals and the plastic or rubber casing. The typical lead
battery consists of 17% metallic lead, 50% lead oxide/sulfate, 24% electrolyte,
5% plastics and 4% (and reducing) inert residuals.
F. Principles of hydro-metallurgical battery recycling
Carlos Frias discussed the environmental effects of hydro-metallurgical
processing of used lead acid batteries. In addition to the treatment of battery
pastes, he reviewed current and best practices with respect to the treatment of
the drained electrolyte, metallic grids and connectors. He noted that efficient
separation of the various battery components facilitates further treatment, and
that most of the negative environmental impacts arise from the composition of
the battery pastes, especially the 20% sulfur content.
Hydro-metallurgical contributions to lead acid battery processing include
treatment of the drainage acids, battery paste desulfurisation, treatment of the
pastes, recycling of baghouse fumes, ashes, slags and old slag deposits and
contaminated soils, and treatment of the lead sulfide concentrates. Of all the
hydro-metallurgical options for the treatment of pastes, only the PLACID process
has demonstrated complete technical viability. Whilst PLACID technology can
completely replace traditional pyro-metallurgical recycling, partial
hydro-metallurgical recycling can complement rather than substitute conventional
furnace technology. A brine/acid solution is used for lead dissolution and
electrowinning. There are no liquid effluents, just inert leaching residues. All
slags, ashes and drosses are recycled to the PLACID line and the acid used in
the process regenerates. Sulfurous gases are eliminated and gaseous emissions
are eliminated in the hydro-metallurgical process and are minimal in the
combined hydro-metallurgical and traditional furnace technology. This is because
the lead compound produced can be melted at low temperature.
The PLINT process is advocated for the treatment of pastes, and is also
appropriate for re-treating old slag deposits and contaminated soils. The
process is similar to the PLACID process, but it produces a pure lead hydroxide
instead of electrolytic lead.
G. Principles of pyro-metallurgical battery recycling
Edmundo Esguerrra, Environmental Engineer with Philippine Recyclers Inc.
(PRI), described the high temperature extraction of lead from used lead acid
batteries. The technology involves pre-treament (including crushing, screening
and sorting), desulfurization, smelting and refining. He reviewed the various
furnace configurations used in smelting lead, and the secondary lead refining
process. Environmental controls, such as afterburning, the use of baghouse
filtration systems, wet gas scrubbers, ventilation hoods and the treatment of
wastewater were also described.
|