|
Introduction
The United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), in conjunction with the
International Lead Management Centre (ILMC) and the Carl Duisberg Gesellschaft
(CDG), convened a participatory training workshop designed to familiarise
participants with the Environmental Technology Assessment (EnTA) process and to
develop their understanding by engaging them in a practical application of the
EnTA methodology, using automotive battery recycling as a case study. UNEP
viewed the workshop as part of its efforts to encourage the uptake of an
emerging methodology for assessing the environmental and related impacts of
industrial process, and other, technologies. To facilitate this uptake of EnTA,
UNEP has prepared an environmental technology assessment (EnTA) Manual,
Anticipating the Environmental Effects of Technology.
Part of the workshop programme was devoted to characterising and illustrating
the importance of macro and micro economic factors in establishing the
parameters for a viable and thereby sustainable industrial process.
EnTA is well suited to developing countries and those in transition as it
facilitates selection of the "appropriate" technology, to suit the
environmental (including social and economic) circumstances and priorities of
the country or region. Hence there was particular value in conducting the
workshop in South East Asia, and including several participants from other
regions and countries in transition.
The Workshop targeted those working in industry, Governmental environmental,
regulatory and trade agencies, and in non-governmental organisations. Such
people are among those often required to assess the environmental impact of a
range of technologies, or make discerning choices between various competing
processes.
Focus , Objectives and Outputs of the
Training Workshop
The focus of the workshop was to assess the environmental and related
performances of current and emerging technologies used in automotive battery
collection and recycling sectors in Southeast Asia, particularly in the
Philippines, including measures that enhance collection rates and avoid used
batteries entering the waste stream.
The objectives of the workshop were to ensure that participants would:
- Understand the principles of economically viable and environmentally sound
lead acid battery collection and recycling;
- Be able to use the methodology described in the Environmental Technology
Assessment (EnTA) Manual, Anticipating the Environmental Effects of Technology,
as a tool with which to evaluate the environmental soundness of technologies and
of procedures in the secondary lead industry, with a special focus on used
automotive lead acid battery collection and recycling; and
- Be capable of applying the lessons learned to assess the environmental
impacts of a wider range of technologies.
Consistent with the above objectives, the outputs of the workshop were:
- 36 delegates and 4 other participants trained in the use of EnTA to evaluate
the environmental impacts of process technologies, especially those related to
recycling used lead acid batteries;
- Publication of an evaluated and revised EnTA Manual, ready for worldwide use
by Governments and industry as a selection tool for sound environmental
management of recycling and other processes; and
- Preparation of a model workshop, and publication of a trainers' manual that
would facilitate replication of the workshop in other countries and regions, and
focus on a range of process technologies.
To achieve these objectives extensive use was made of the
simplified Environmental Technology Assessment (EnTA) Manual, Anticipating the
Environmental Effects of Technology, prepared jointly by UNEP's Production and
Consumption Unit and its International Environmental Technology Centre, both of
UNEP's Division of Technology, Industry and Economics (DTIE).
Participants from governmental environmental and other agencies,
from industry, educational institutions and non-governmental organisations, were
trained in the use and application of EnTA, with battery recycling used as a
case study. The newly acquired knowledge and skills were intended to provide the
basis for participants to make valid assessments of the real and potential
environmental performances of the chosen battery recycling processes and, where
applicable, make recommendations regarding procedural and technology
improvements to the industrial sector, in order to achieve higher levels of
health and environmental protection. The workshop was also intended to give
participants the opportunity to equip themselves with the methods, tools and
materials they could use to conduct EnTA training courses in their domestic
institutions and national organisations.
Background to the
Workshop
The potentially serious health and environmental impacts of
inappropriate and uncontrolled practices in the collection and recycling of
lead-acid batteries are well documented. All stages of the used battery
collection and re-processing operations are associated with potentially adverse
human health and environmental risks, for both small-scale operators and major
plants.
UNEP's technical report Recyclage des Batteries Plomb-Acide et
Environnement, published in 1999, provides a global review of many of the
technological options for improving the performance of the secondary lead
industry. A report, in English, outlining the principles of sound battery
recycling will be prepared in 2000, as a joint initiative of UNEP and ILMC. This
report will contain information about the appropriate management of battery
recycling operations, including best practices and cost effective environmental
options for developing countries.
As part of the United Nations Conference on Trade and
Development (UNCTAD) project on the impact of the proposed Basel Ban Amendment,
ILMC and UNCTAD have undertaken an extensive study of automotive battery
collection and recycling in the Philippines, focusing on the need to restructure
the formal and informal sectors, and taking into account relevant Filipino
social, economic and environmental needs and priorities. The Manila Office of
UNDP and the Philippine Government's Department of Trade and Industry and
Environmental Management Bureau (EMB) also support this study, and compliance
with the resulting recommendations.
The export-import of automotive batteries has become an element
of the work of the Basel Convention, especially the procedures to regulate the
trade in recyclable hazardous wastes. The use of environmentally sound
technologies for recycling is one of the key elements in the global debate on
this issue. However, the definition of "environmentally sound" needs
to be expressed in operational and scientific terms that facilitate the
selection of appropriate recycling technologies and procedures, by both the
private sector and governments.
In order to encourage the wider use of EnTA, UNEP has simplified
the procedure, as described in the new Environmental Technology Assessment
Manual, Anticipating the Environmental Effects of Technology. The revised Manual
is for use by government officials, consultants and company process and
environmental managers, to identify the health, environmental and social
implications of any technology through application of EnTA.
The workshop combined all the above elements into a training
format that lead to the practical application of the EnTA methodology by the
delegates. The workshop also provided an opportunity for UNEP to review and
evaluate the EnTA Manual and to share policy advice.
Workshop Sponsorship
The four-day regional workshop in Manila was funded, sponsored,
or in other ways supported by the following cooperating organizations:
-
UNEP - Division of Technology, Industry and Economics (DTIE) (Production and
Consumption Unit, and International Environmental Technology Centre) and the
Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific (ROAP);
-
International Lead Management Center (ILMC), USA;
-
Carl Duisberg Gesellschaft (CDG), Germany;
-
Philippine Recyclers Inc., Republic of the Philippines;
-
Technicas Reunidas (Torrejon), Spain; and
-
UNCTAD - International Trade and Commodities Division, Trade, Environment and
Development Section, Geneva Office, Switzerland.
Workshop Programme
The workshop programme is presented in Annex 1. The interactive
and participatory workshop comprised the following major components:
-
Opening;
-
Summaries of national reports on lead acid battery recycling and environmental
management;
-
Review and discussion of environmental assessment techniques, with a focus on
EnTA;
-
Technical presentations and discussions related to:
- Economics of sustainable environmentally sound battery recycling;
-
Construction and design of the modern recyclable lead acid battery;
-
Principles of hydro-metallurgical battery recycling; and
-
Principles of pyro-metallurgical battery recycling;
-
The methods and practices of EnTA;
-
Practical, field-based assessment exercises in EnTA;
-
Preparation and presentation of reports of practical working groups;
-
Preparation of personal action plans;
-
Review and evaluation of:
-
Close
|