INSIGHT, September '99 Edition
PHYTOREMEDIATION - A Cost-Effective
Remediation Method
Phytoremediation refers to the use of plants for cleaning up
contaminants in soil, groundwater, surface water and air. It encompasses:
1) phytoextraction or phytoconcentration, where the contaminant is
concentrated in the roots, stem and foliage of the plant; 2)
phytodegradation, where plant enzymes help catalyze breakdown of the
contaminant molecule; 3) rhizosphere biodegradation, where plant roots
release nutrients to microorganisms which are active in biodegradation of
the contaminant molecule; 4) volatilisation, where organics are transpired
through plant leaves; and, 5) stabilisation, where the plant converts the
contaminant into a form which is not bioavailable, or the plant prevents
the spreading of a contaminant plume. The principal application of
phytoremediation is for lightly contaminated soils, sludges and waters
where the material to be treated is at a shallow or medium depth and the
area to be treated is large, so that agronomic techniques are economical
and applicable for both planting and harvesting. In addition, the site
owner must be prepared to accept a longer remediation period.
Although phytoremediation has not been used extensively, it has many
advantages: 1) It is low cost compared to current "mechanical"
methods for soil remediation. 2) It is passive and solar driven. 3) It is
faster than natural attenuation. 4) The amount of contaminated material
going to landfills can be greatly reduced. 5) Energy can be recovered from
controlled combustion of harvested biomass. 6) And, overall, it is low
impact and public acceptance is expected to be high. Still,
phytoremediation is new and not fully developed. There is little
regulatory experience with phytoremediation, and it has to be considered
on a site by site basis. Furthermore, the intrinsic characteristics of
phytoremediation limit its application.
Some other limitations of phytoremediation are:
- It is generally slower than most other treatment methods and is
climate dependent.
- In most cases, the contamination to be treated must be shallow.
- It usually requires nutrient addition, and mass transfer is limited.
- High metal and other contaminant concentrations can be toxic to some
plants.
- Access to the site must be controlled, as contaminants being treated
by phytoremediation may be transferred across media (i.e., may enter
groundwater or may bioaccumulate in animals).
- For mixed contaminant sites (i.e., organic and inorganic) more than
one phytoremediation method may be required.
- The site must be large enough to utilise agricultural machinery for
planting and harvesting.
Although phytoremediation as a cleanup technique is not yet widely
applied, momentum for its use is expected to build, particularly in
application niches where other technologies are less suitable or do not
exist. There will also likely be combined applications of bioremediation
and phytoremediation. Figure 1 illustrates how other remediation
techniques compare to phytoremediation.
Figure 1: A comparison of
phytoremediation and other remediation techniques.
| Treatment
Name |
Advantages Compared to
Phytoremediation |
Disadvantages
Compared to Phytoremediation |
| Solidification/ Stabilisation |
Not seasonally dependent; well established; rapid;
applicable to most metals and organics; simple process. |
Site is not restored to original
form; leaching of the contaminant is a risk; can result in a significant
volume increase. |
Soil Flushing/ Soil Washing |
Not seasonally dependent, except in cold climates;
methods well established for several types of sites and contamination. |
Metals removal using water requires
PH change; additional treatment steps and chemicals add complexity and
cost. |
| Bioremediation |
Established and accepted; a bioreactor can be utilised
for ex-situ work; may be faster than phytoremediation. |
Requires nutrient addition at a much
greater level than phytoremediation; applicable to organics only. |
| Electrokinetics |
Not seasonally dependent; can be used in conjunction
with phytoremediation to enhance rhizosphere biodegradation. |
Useful for soil only, not wetlands;
uniformity of soil conditions is required. |
| Chemical Reduction/ Oxidation |
Not seasonally dependent; relatively short treatment
time frame; usually off-site. |
Requires excavation; uses chemical
additives; fertility of the soil may be damaged. |
Excavation/ Disposal |
Rapid, immediate solution for site owner. |
Transfers contaminants to landfill;
does not treat. |
|