Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Municipal Solid Waste Management>
Regional Overviews and Information Sources
Europe
2.3 Topic e: Landfills
Landfilling is an unavoidable component of all European
waste systems. In certain Northern European countries, less than half of the
waste may be landfilled; while in southern countries like Greece and Spain, or
Eastern European countries such as Hungary and Poland, virtually all waste finds
its way to land burial. The European Union Draft Landfill Directive identifies
three kinds of landfills: for hazardous waste, for municipal waste, and for
inert materials. Monofills - landfills for one particular material - are also
recognized in the directive.
In virtually every European country, reliance on small, largely uncontrolled
municipal landfills was the norm twenty years ago; in many countries this is
only beginning to change. Small municipal landfills, often in wetlands or low
areas, are generally uncontrolled, do not require weighing of the waste, charge
no fees, have no environmental controls, and are frequently burned over to
reduce the volume of the waste. No cover is used, and closure is informal, if it
takes place at all.
Within certain countries, grassroots and/or political concern over
groundwater, soil, and health generally have led to an emphasis on more
environmentally sound landfills. Supranational policy initiatives at the
European Community level have strengthened this trend, contributing to a gradual
shift from smaller, uncontrolled landfills, with largely unmonitored
environmental and water quality effects and costs, to larger, generally regional
systems with pollution control features. These "modern" landfills are
carefully sited, and access and dumping are controlled and monitored. They
typically require incoming waste to be weighed, and to be paid for on a per-ton
basis. The characteristics of such state-of-the-art landfills are described in
the Sound Practices section of this book.
Increased attention paid to environmental controls usually results in rising
costs for landfill construction, operation, and closure; this in turn tends to
force the economy of scale of newer, more environmentally sound landfills,
upwards. The resulting regionalization of solid waste disposal is a significant
factor in most European countries, and creates side effects ranging from the
need to create regional solid waste authorities to the need to build transfer
stations.
Design and construction of modern landfills is more expensive than simple
dumping, and these facilities may also be difficult to site. Public resistance
is less of a factor in Europe than in North America, but still plays a role in
siting. Environmental controls push costs upwards. This pressures developers to
build larger landfills, which serve a region rather than a single municipality
and are typically more cost-effective. Regional landfills tend to be larger,
more identifiable capital projects, and cost recovery usually requires a tipping
fee. European governments do not always choose to recover the full amortized
costs of construction and operation of landfills through the tipping fee, and
these fees tend to be set in part according to policy objectives, such as
discouraging open dumping. In some cases, landfill fees are arbitrarily set
higher than costs to discourage disposal or force costs onto producers or
generators; in other cases, they are price-controlled to encourage legal
disposal and discourage illegal dumping.
The decomposition of putrescible materials in landfills produces landfill
gas, a combination of methane and carbon dioxide. This gas can be vented,
flared, or recovered for use, as described in the "Landfills" portion
of the Sound Practices section. Some gas recovered at landfills in Europe is
simply flared, while in other cases the energy is recovered. A tragic landfill
accident occurred in 1993 near Istanbul, when an explosion of methane and other
gases caused decomposed waste to flow out of the landfill, covering part of a
settlement nearby and killing 39 people. In Izmir, Turkey, there is a landfill
with newly installed gas capture capability.
There is also considerable experience in Europe with bioreacting landfills,
in which leachate is recirculated to maintain optimal moisture levels for
biodegradation to occur. This process is discussed further in the Sound
Practices section.
|