Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Municipal Solid Waste Management>
Regional Overviews and Information Sources
North America
2.5 Topic d: Incineration
Most of the MSW combustion currently practiced in North
America incorporates energy recovery in the form of steam, which is used either
to drive a turbine to generate electricity or directly for heating or cooling.
In the process, the volume of solid waste is reduced by up to 90% and its weight
by up to 75%. In past years it was common to simply burn MSW in incinerators to
reduce its volume and weight, but energy recovery has become more prevalent
since the 1980s. While about 30% of the MSW stream was incinerated without
energy recovery in 1960, this has decreased to about 1% today. Currently,
waste-to-energy (WTE) incineration is used to manage about 10-15% of the MSW
stream in North America.
It should be noted, however, that the recent development of regional
landfills providing relatively inexpensive disposal capacity has made it more
difficult for capital-intensive WTE plants to compete. Additionally, court
decisions restricting communities' ability to control the flow of their wastes
has made it more difficult for local authorities to meet contractual obligations
to WTE plants.
The amount of solid waste processed in WTE facilities varies significantly by
region. The northeastern US currently incinerates and recovers energy from over
40% of its solid waste, while many states incinerate less than 2% of the solid
waste they generate. There are currently about 160 WTE facilities in the US. In
Canada, the number is much lower. In fact, the province of Ontario was only
operating three incinerator facilities in 1991 and placed a ban on any new
facilities being constructed.
Specific technologies
The three most widely used and technically proven WTE technologies used in
North America are (a) mass-burn combustion, (b) modular combustion, and (c)
refuse-derived-fuel production and combustion. Over the last several years,
local governments have largely favored mass-burn systems that recover
electricity over other WTE technologies, such as modular units and steam-only
processes. Several other emerging WTE technologies have been pilot-tested, but
are not yet commercially proven. These include fluidized-bed combustion,
anaerobic digestion, gasification, pyrolysis, and other related processes that
convert solid waste to gaseous, liquid, or solid fuel through thermal
processing.
Mass-burn systems are the predominant form of WTE in North America. Operating
mass-burn facilities process about 60% by weight of the solid waste from which
energy is recovered. Mass-burn systems generally consist of either two or three
combustion units ranging in capacity from 50 to 1,000 tons per day; thus,
facility capacity ranges from about 100 to 3,000 tons per day. About 90% of
operating mass-burn facilities generate electricity. These facilities can accept
refuse that has undergone little preprocessing other than the removal of
oversized items, such as refrigerators and sofas. Although this versatility
makes mass-burn facilities convenient and flexible, local programs to separate
household hazardous wastes (e.g., cleaners and pesticides) and recover certain
recyclables are necessary to help ensure environmentally responsible
incineration and resource conservation.
Modular combustors are usually prefabricated units with relatively small
capacities of between 5 and 120 tons of solid waste per day. Typical facilities
have between one and four units for a total plant capacity of about 15 to 400
tons per day. Because of their small size, only about 7% of solid waste that
undergoes energy recovery in North America is processed at modular WTE
facilities. The majority of modular units produce steam as the sole energy
product. Because of their small capacity, modular combustors are generally used
in smaller communities or for commercial and industrial operations. Their
prefabricated design gives modular facilities the advantage of shorter
construction time frames. On average, capital costs per ton of capacity are
lower for modular units than for mass- burn and refuse-derived fuel plants.
"Refuse-derived fuel" (RDF) commonly refers to solid waste that has
been mechanically processed to produce a storable, transportable, and more
homogeneous fuel for combustion. RDF production and combustion plants are
described in the Sound Practices section. As of 1991, 14 facilities in the US
processed RDF for off-site combustion; 12 facilities combusted RDF in dedicated
boilers on-site; and 7 facilities combusted RDF with other fuel (i.e., co-fire
RDF). The vast majority of RDF combustion facilities generate electricity. On
average, capital costs per ton of capacity are higher for RDF combustion units
than for mass-burn and modular WTE units.
Several emerging WTE technologies are at varying stages of research and
development, and could become available commercially in the future. These
processes include fluidized-bed combustion, pyrolysis and gasification, and
anaerobic digestion. Pyrolysis and gasification, and anaerobic digestion are
discussed in the section on composting. In a fluidized-bed combustor, instead of
a grate supporting a layer of solid fuel, the furnace contains a bed of sand or
limestone supported by an air distribution system. Several facilities in the US
use fluidized beds to co-fire RDF with other fuels (e.g., sewage sludge) and at
least two facilities dedicated to fluidized-bed solid waste combustion are under
development. They are large-scale plants that incorporate front-end processing
with materials recovery.
Environmental concerns
In North America the major public concerns about the environmental risks of
WTE facilities are the potential emission of contaminants into the air through
exhaust stacks (i.e., particulates, nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide, carbon
monoxide, metals, acid gases, and dioxins) and into water through ash leachate.
US and most state and provincial air pollution control laws and regulations,
however, have been strengthened in recent years to specifically address
potential impacts from WTE air emissions. To meet these standards, modern
pollution control equipment effectively removes the vast majority of the
emissions of concern. The major air emission control technologies employed in
North American WTE facilities are fabric filters or baghouses, electrostatic
precipitators, and scrubbers. The Sound Practices section contains more detail
on these issues. Integration of WTE with the other elements of the solid waste
management system, such as recycling and landfilling, is another important issue
in North America.
|