Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Municipal Solid Waste Management>
Regional Overviews and Information Sources
North America
2.5 Topic c: Composting
Upwards of 5% of the MSW stream in North America is now
managed through centralized composting programs, which were insignificant prior
to the mid-1980s. The compostable portion of MSW can constitute 30-60% of a
community's waste stream. Composting programs have been designed for a variety
of organic waste streams, including yard wastes (grass trimmings, leaves, or
tree prunings), food wastes, agricultural wastes, and wastewater treatment
sludge. Another alternative, which has been used only on a limited basis in
North America, is mixed waste composting. Mixed waste processing facilities
accept unsorted MSW in the same form as it would be received at a landfill or a
waste-to-energy facility, and separate recyclable materials. The relatively
small community of Guelph, Ontario, has been operating such a facility
successfully since early 1996.
There are currently about 20 MSW composting facilities operating in the US,
12 of which are relatively small-scale, processing less than 50 tons per day. In
addition, a composting facility can benefit from bans on leaf and yard wastes at
landfill sites. Encouraging residents to undertake their own composting
activities can reduce the amount of materials requiring centralized composting,
thereby reducing the costs of such programs. This can be supplemented by
legislative changes, as undertaken by the City of Toronto in 1996, where lawn
clippings are no longer allowed to be landfilled or taken for centralized
composting. Residents can either compost them or leave them on the lawn. The
number of yard waste composting programs in the US now totals over 3,200. This
growth was spurred on by yard waste disposal bans that have been enacted by
about half of the states. Composting is the primary method of diverting yard
trimmings; other management methods include land application and mulching. Many
communities have also started programs to collect Christmas trees and make them
into wood chips, which residents can collect for their gardens. Canada currently
has over 160 composting projects throughout the country.
Like recycling, the success of a composting program is determined in large
part by markets for the material. Currently, most communities find that it is
possible to give compost away, but not to sell it. In order to market compost
commercially, communities need to be able to provide users with a steady supply
of a high quality product. This becomes more difficult as composting programs
expand to include more materials. With yard waste composting, for example, the
ratio of grass to leaves to brush varies with the season. At certain times of
the year nutrients are sometimes added to the final product to maintain
standards. With careful planning and experimentation, communities can use
diverse materials to produce several products. Some states are establishing
standards for compost that should help give potential users more confidence in
the product.
Composting methods can be as simple as a small pile in the backyard or as
complex as a multi-million dollar centralized in-vessel tank system. Low-tech
methods can be implemented inexpensively, but take longer to produce a finished
product. High-tech methods shorten the compost time, but have higher capital
costs for buildings and equipment.
Backyard composting and mulching is a source reduction activity that saves
money for both the municipality and the homeowner. Some households compost food
scraps in a backyard pile or in a composting bin, typically for use in vegetable
or flower gardens. Grass clippings can be left on freshly mowed lawns instead of
being bagged. If the clippings are short enough, they will fall through to the
ground and be assimilated into the soil. Leaves can be shredded in a special
mulching lawn mower. Small branches and brush can be shredded in a wood-chipper
and used for landscaping, or if sufficiently reduced in size, added to a compost
pile. Many communities in North America have developed programs to encourage
backyard composting, by offering educational materials and by distributing
composting bins. A number of communities buy the bins in bulk and distribute
them free of charge or for a nominal fee. The successful program in Vancouver,
Canada differs from this approach; they charge $25 for the bins, judging that
the expenditure solidifies a commitment by the resident to actually use the bin.
The City of Seattle has implemented a sophisticated multi-point composting
program that uses a combination of curbside pickup, drop-off, and backyard
composting elements. The City sponsors four composting demonstration sites,
three in urban gardens and one next to an urban market. The City also funds a
backyard composting education program run by a local organization of urban
gardeners that trains volunteers to be proficient at composting. The volunteers
then perform 40 hours of community outreach and education. Toronto operates a
similar program through the Recycling Council of Ontario. In 1989, 5% of both
Seattle s and Toronto s total waste stream was composted by residents.
Anaerobic digestion most often refers to the production of methane from the
organic fraction of solid waste in enclosed, controlled reactors. No controlled,
commercial, solid waste anaerobic digestors have yet operated in the US. A
large-scale demonstration facility (RefCoM) was operated in Florida from 1978 to
1985, but was shut down when the demonstration period ended. Due to increasing
interest in the development of low-cost, environmentally acceptable alternative
energy sources, however, methane production through anaerobic digestion has
become the subject of research and development efforts throughout the world.
There has been interest in North America in pyrolysis, a process that
chemically and physically changes biomass through the addition of heat and in
the absence of oxygen (or under partial oxidation). The end products of
pyrolysis include a solid char, a liquid char (pyrolysis oil), and a gas (pyrolysis
gas, synthesis gas, or syngas), all of which are marketable forms of energy.
Although several pyrolysis and related gasification systems have been designed
and constructed in the past two decades, most have been demonstration and
laboratory-scale systems. The larger-scale demonstration plants in the US
experienced technology problems and are no longer operating. There are currently
no commercial-scale solid waste pyrolysis or gasification systems operating in
North America.
|