|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Planning and Management of Lakes and
Reservoirs: An Integrated Approach to Eutrophication>
CHAPTER 7. MANAGEMENT
7.7. Conclusions and Recommendations
Lake and reservoir environments are dynamic, changing as the economic
activities in its surrounds change. Many of the large impoundments were
planned when world awareness of environmental issues, especially
ecological management of freshwater resources was low. The management
structures put in place then reflected the concerns of that era. Now these
issues are critical for the well being of humanity. Sates need to ensure
functional and durable mechanisms for the management of lakes and
reservoirs, mechanisms that are able to respond to ever changing
challenges. These include proper institutions, adequate funding for both
management and research, stakeholders participation, and functional legal
frameworks at both national and international levels.
As the need for energy continues to increase in Latin America, more
reservoirs will be built up either by the public or private sector. The
introduction of management plans prior to the reservoir construction and
operation is an economic and social issue of relevance. The filling phase
of reservoirs is the fundamental event that sets up the pattern of
succession. It is fundamental to establish a monitoring programme that
will follow the changes from the beginning of the impoundment. The
management of reservoirs, and specially those in Latin America, is a
complex operation that needs permanent input from basic sciences. The
knowledge about mechanisms of functioning is thus essential for
management. Management includes the recovery and inputs to the
construction of new reservoirs in order to optimize multiple uses, prevent
eutrophication and deterioration. Adaptive management should be developed
for each reservoir or a cascade of reservoirs. Each case is unique.
Management has to grow with knowledge and should be adapted to multiple
uses along the process of succession. Management needs the contribution of
limnologists, engineers, biologists, operational managers, and
decision-makers. A certain level of prediction, based on empirical
observations and experiments, is necessary for the management of
reservoirs in Latin America. Countries like Argentina, Brazil, Chile, and
Mexico, are reviewing the status of the regulations and improving them,
thus enhancing law enforcement for the management of reservoirs.
As compared with lakes, water reservoirs are more sustainable against
the growing biological load. It is explained by the larger share of
mineral particles in the balance of sediments, due to the abrasion of the
reservoirs' shores. For this reason, the shores' abrasion plays a positive
role co-precipitating and burying under bottom sediments man-made
pollutants, including the phosphorus compounds. On average, the internal
phosphorus load in reservoirs is less than in lakes.
The analysis of the ecological state of the well-studied water
reservoirs in Russia demonstrates that, in spite of the considerable
phosphorus load, most of the largest reservoirs are mesotrophic with the
features of slowly developing eutrophication.
Management of the non-point external nutrients load is complicated due
to very large territories of the reservoirs' basins in Russia (104
to 106 km²). To increase the self-purification capacity
of the valley reservoirs, an original method is suggested. The reservoir
has to be converted into a polysectional water body with one or more
WPSs.The method is based on the control of the internal water exchange of
those water reservoirs that have the yearly amplitude of the water level
over 2 to 3 m.
Any water reservoir has its individual hydrological features that change
in accordance with variations of hydrometeorological conditions. For this
reason, the design of the optimal location of the intersectional dams is
always individual. It should be based on field measurements of the water
and compounds balances together with the mathematical modeling of the
processes of water exchange and self-purification in the ecosystem of the
reconstructed reservoir.
Other examples from the world show the role of institutional and legal
frameworks in the management of lakes and reservoirs, especially with
respect to eutrophication. Technical know-how alone, without sound
institutional support and good governance, is unlikely succeed in
sustainable water quality management. At international level shared water
resources needs clear conventions in which the participating states'
responsibilities and privileges are clear, and where clear protocols for
management co-operation and dispute resolution are transparent.
Climate change will affect lake and reservoir hydrology. In the tropics
the IPCC scenarios indicate a possible decrease in precipitation and a
possible increase in evaporation by up to 40% for 1 to 2°C. These
changes will have pronounced effects on the storage of lakes and
reservoirs. The African great lakes, for example, have delicate
hydrological budgets, with normally less than 10% of watershed run-off
appearing as stream flow. A decrease in precipitation and increase in
evaporation could convert these lakes into a closed watershed. Where the
outflow represents only a small percentage of total inflow, increased
evaporation alone could result in an interrupted outflow, as recently
shown. The vulnerability of medium seized reservoirs in Southern Africa
was shown. Recent reports from Ghana also show that even in the humids
tropics the ecological effects would be felt in impacts of increased
temperature on lake's stratification. At high temperatures, stable
thermoclines form with only a small temperature differences between the
hyperlimnion and hypolimnion is less than 1°C (see Lake Victoria in
International Lake Environment Committee (ILEC), 1994). In eutrophic
conditions, these stable stratification conditions will enhance oxygen
depletion, production of hydrogen sulphide, and possibly lead to changes
of fish species composition. Algal, as well as macrophyte growth rates
will be enhanced. These changes will have significant economic impacts in
fisheries and the potable water supply. Therefore they should be
considered in the future planning of construction of new reservoirs and in
management of the present lakes and reservoirs.
|