|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Planning and Management of Lakes and
Reservoirs: An Integrated Approach to Eutrophication>
CHAPTER 4. PUBLIC AWARENESS AND ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION
4.3. Public Participation
4.3.4. Stimulation and Integration of Stakeholders
Public bodies, through their activities, serve to integrate and
stimulate public and cultural opinion. This results, among others things,
from the commitment of community members representing various professions,
opinions, and interests to work on a problem of common concern, such as
water eutrophication control. This is particularly important, especially
in the context of broad public education. This issue is discussed in the
next section of this chapter. To benefit fully from the opportunities
connected with activities of these organizations, their work should be
demonstrated to the community through the media, also by comparison with
other organizations, including the local authorities.
Role of scientific groups and non-governmental organizations
Scientific groups and non-governmental organizations play a major role
in the public participation process. Scientists are among the first to
point out evidence of significant environmental risks and changes
resulting from the growing intensity of human activities. Interactions
between scientists, citizens groups, non-governmental organizations, and
the media create, an increasing public awareness of environmental issues.
This, in turn, creates public pressures that stimulate the decision-makers
to act.
Non-governmental organizations have a special role in the integration of
communities. As independent entities they constitute an important
stimulating element toward the public, authenticating the social dialogue
and undertaken activities. They are usually supra-local organizations,
experienced in public environmental education, particularly in conducting
educational campaigns, organization of education for children and the
young, and public involvement in decision-making processes.
Non-governmental organizations often include appropriate practitioners who
can plan and conduct public dialogue. Through their contacts with
international organizations, they can also be useful in finding financial
support. Their contribution can add a larger dimension to supra-local
activities, thereby strengthening the environmental lobby of a local
community.
The success and effectiveness of the activities of public agencies
depend to a great extent on the organization of their work and logistics.
Appropriate and very careful preparation of all meetings and published
materials is the key to success. Numerous public relations manuals
describe, in detail, how to achieve this.
Example: Public Participation in Brazil
"The Citizens for Water Movement"
In Brazil, water is considered an abundant natural
resource, when compared with the current demand, although there are very
dry areas where water is so precious as to be used only to meet human
needs. Although Brazil holds 8% of all fresh water on the surface of our
planet, the situation of water in the country is delicate. Most of the
available water (80%) is located in the Amazon Region and the remaining
20% is unequally distributed among the other regions, where 95% of the
Brazilian population lives.
"The Citizens for Water Movement" is an
initiative of the Secretariat of Water Resources of the Ministry of
Environment, Water Resources, and the Legal Amazon Region that
acknowledges and reinforces the efforts of individuals and organizations
that are carrying out relevant actions for the preservation of water. The
movement will enhance the profile, provide support to, and help organize,
those who feel compelled to actively participate in the management of
water resources.
It is a way of telling citizens, inside and outside
government, that the government can do much, but not everything,
particularly when dealing with springs and multiple water uses, which are
close to individual citizens and far away from government offices.
"Citizens for Water" is a public movement that
includes citizens inside and outside the government. The efforts to
enhance the actions of citizens to protect water resources were initiated
by the government, but any non-governmental organization could have done
it. Thus, all individuals and organizations that participate in the
movement belong to the network of "Citizens for Water".
It is important to emphasize that some individuals and
organizations were already working in this important area before the
movement began its efforts to strengthen and acknowledge their actions.
Who are these citizens?
Individuals and organizations working to protect water,
together or separately, in an ethical manner, within and without the
government, participate in the movement.
Anyone who considers water as an element of nature, which
should be preserved, respected, and used as any other element of nature,
is a "Citizen for Water".
Who participates in the movement?
The various types of participation can, and must, be
established by the interested parties, individually, in groups,
committees, etc. Citizens are the technicians who disseminate
information, fishermen who protect the life of fish,
environmentalists committed to the preservation of ecosystems, professors
who teach environmental protection, farmers who care for the water
within their farms, manufacturers who treat industrial wastes, and
citizens who dispose properly the garbage because they know that a
plain candy wrapper thrown on the sidewalk will end up first in the
gutter, then in a stream and finally in the river.
Presently about 20 cities in Brazil have a reference centre
and are acting locally at schools, churches, professional societies, and
other water users associations.
The participation of the Secretariat of Water Resources
(SRH) began with the publication of a newsletter aiming at the collection
and dissemination of information about the actions of the "Citizens
for Water". The SRH also operates a Reference Centre whose functions
include promoting conferences and bibliographic surveys, as well as
facilitating, coordinating, and encouraging the multiplication of the
actions of the Citizens for Water Movement.
An ombudsman for environment: the experience of São
Paulo State, Brazil (for more information see section 3.4.2., Chapter
3 of this publication).
São Paulo is the most developed state in the
Brazilian Federal Republic. Located in the Parana/Plata River Basin, it
encompasses 241 000 km² and hosts 33 million inhabitants, which
implies a demographic density of 137 inh/km². In a radius of 150 km
centred in the City of São Paulo, the density increases to more
than 500 inh/km² . The large urban population in the São Paulo
Metropolitan area and in 530 towns (70% of urban population) is
experiencing a wide range of environmental problems of which
deforestation, eutrophication, and toxicity of water and soil are
outstanding ones.
State surface water, on average, has an availability of
3140m³/s. With existing hydraulic structures (mainly reservoirs) it
is possible to regulate 70% of that value or 2105 m³/s. Groundwater
flow is high in at least two-thirds of the São Paulo State
territory. The base flow of the state's rivers is 1300 km³/s.
Water demands on the state are 354 m³/s of which 87 m³/s
are for domestic urban supply, 112 m³/s for industrial water supply
and 154 m³/s for irrigation. In the year 2010 the State of São
Paulo demands will be 800 m³/s or 42% of the whole water
availability. Forest cover is 2% of the original vegetation cover at the
beginning of the century.
In order to overcome all the environmental problems
associated with the industrial, agricultural (agribusiness is the main
agricultural activity) development, and urban concentration, a new
institutional organization was created. This organization is an
ombudsman for the environment for São Paulo that heads a
juridical and law regulation system for the whole state. Each town has an
ombudsman that receives requests from the general public to enforce the
law in certain local environmental problems. The ombudsman is supported by
the local universities or research institutes that provide the technical
and scientific background needed to enforce the legislation.
This institutional organization has given new possibilities
of environmental control on the state, mobilizing associations that
actively participate in conservation, recovery and disaster prevention in
environmental problems, in general, and particularly in the control of
eutrophication and pollution of water.
Example: Czech Republic Experiences on Public
Involvement in Decision Making Processes Activities Addressed Lakes and
Water Reservoirs Eutrophication - Existing Status
One of the main barriers in effective public participation
in environmental decision-making processes in the Czech Republic is
limitation in the accessibility of environmental information to the
public.
On the one side, there are several state institutions that
monitor water quality level. Almost all these institutions are state owned
or are being transferred into private companies. Because of weak financial
conditions, they expect to sell data to get money for their further
activities. They provide data only exceptionally, mostly to students or to
the institution belonging to the same ministry. They inform town council,
journalists and decision-makers when they are asked. However, the problem
is that people do not know what to ask about. In general, the institutions
looking after water quality are isolated from the public and do not
provide clear, expletive information.
In some cities, particularly in small villages or towns
where the concentration of nitrates in local water sources could be more
than 10 mg/l (upper limit for newborn is 15 mg/l), the information on
water quality is provided in public posters, but relevant explanation is
missing. None of the articles published in newspapers explains the
relationship between nutrient level in drinking water and quality of water
resource. The eutrophication issue is not used in any of the articles.
It could be assumed that people are informed on drinking
water quality in case they have their own particular interest. This is a
good example showing that public awareness increasing activities can do
very much in changing this pattern to create a new public understanding of
the peoples own interest and of the relationship between human life
quality and the environment quality.
Non-government organizations (NGOs) activity
NGOs are not able to stimulate successfully the activities
aiming at increasing the public awareness level because of the financial
problems. However, there are some cases where NGOs participated in the
projects on restoration of eutrophicated fishponds by sediment removal.
This project was carried out in the 40 hectares fishpond Vajgar, located
in the district town Jindrichuv Hradec in the southern part of the Czech
Republic. They also participated in the organization of training courses
on the restoration of lakes and streams and the establishment of a Wetland
Training Centre.
Since 1992, in cooperation with a non-profit NGO International
Waterfowl and Wetlands Research Bureau ("Wetlands International"
from 1997), "Wetlands International" training courses are
organized for participants from Eastern and Central European countries on
lake and stream restoration, bog conservation, and management. The
participants are from universities, schools, state authorities, and NGOs.
Two manuals in English were published and distributed among participants.
The manual on Lake Restoration was translated into the Czech language. In
the Czech Republic, the material from the courses was used for seminars
and lectures given at conferences for teachers. They were published in
popular journals, and a publication for school children is under
preparation.
"The foundation Nadatio Flos Aquae" (Czech's NGO
organization) deals with water quality in Brno reservoirs and with
toxicity of blue green algae. The foundation organized seminars and
published one book in the Czech language on water blooms. Such a book can
help decision-makers to orient themselves. Under "Nadatio flos aquae"
a board of experts is concentrated which can consult practical ecological,
hygienical, technological, and toxicological problems connected with water
blooms. Films, books and leaflets produced by "Nadatio flos aquae"
can be a typical example of how a non-profit organization can help public
information and responsible authorities.
|