|
|
 |
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Planning and Management of Lakes and
Reservoirs: An Integrated Approach to Eutrophication>
CHAPTER 3. POLICY, INSTITUTIONAL, AND REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
3.7. Resources
3.7.1. Human Resources
The preparation of qualified human resources is a fundamental component
of any environmental policy to solve problems of eutrophication and water
related issues. Training should be connected with the occupational context
in which planners, administrators, managers, business leaders, senior
bureaucrats, and decision markers work. An important topic in the training
procedure is to take into account political conditions in the different
countries, regions and localities. The characteristics of the training
activities should be based on following criteria:
- Enhancing the ability to integrate environmental management into
planning and into public policy.
- Stressing the need for incorporating scientific basis for the
management, regulatory and policy process.
- Emphasizing the need for a new approach to environmental management
and eutrophication control based on the development of partnerships of
the public private sector and participation of the community.
The orientation for training should give priority to the following
topics:
- Development of the training activity in a regional context, selecting
local or regional case studies, as demonstration units. Orientation for
action and practice: usually training in field seminars with the real
local problems is very effective.
- Discussion and preservation of social dynamics including the
historical background of the eutrophication/water related issues,
economic issues related to water uses on a local scale, social
organization and its interaction with water uses and impacts.
- Comparative aspects should be stressed, e.g., pristine systems versus
eutrophic systems and economic issues involved.
The following basis for training is recommended:
- An ecosystem approach is fundamental for the training activity. The
ecosystem unit to be considered is the watershed.
- The emphasis on biogeophysical, economical, and social problems of
eutrophication control and water related issues are also a priority. It
is essential that the training emphasize, not only descriptive aspects
of the ecosystem structure, but the functional characteristics and the
processes at spatial and temporal scales.
- The analysis and use of local or regional data bases, data evaluation
and interpretation. The usefulness of historical series and the need to
utilize the existing information with maximum capacity, should be
stressed.
- Cost implications, cost analysis of methods and procedures, as well
as mechanism of interactions between academic and research institutions,
NGOs, industry, media, and citizen groups. Seminars with interested
groups are an effective way to identify general demands for training
activities and the content.
Training techniques and instructional methods that can be used are as
follows:
- Project case studies as demonstration units.
- Field seminars with practical observations.
- Problem solving exercises.
- Workshops combined with group dynamics.
- Study tours and excursions.
- Lectures by resource persons followed by group discussions
The training activity and programme should be adjusted to various groups
and their demands. The use of resource persons with a wide experience to
expose conceptual and general problems of eutrophication/water related use
is of significance. This resource person should be supported and interact
with local regional experts with in-depth knowledge of the local region
and their problems. It is also fundamental that the training team involves
scientists (biologists, limnologists) engineers and water managers, and
decision-makers. Two basic characteristics of the training produced should
be considered as priorities:
- Focus on eutrophication on causes, consequences, control,
recovery of freshwater ecosystems and water related issues.
- Articulation of scientific, managerial, regulatory, and
institutional issues. The priority to capacity building at national,
regional, and local levels is fundamental for the consolidation of the
process and the continuity of the actions. This capacity building
includes the whole range of decision-makers, managers, and local
politicians. School teachers can be very instrumental for the capacity
building, being a de-codifier of the scientific information to school
children and the general public. Also, they also can be very important
in monitoring.
Financial Resources
Under conditions of financial constraints it is difficult to implement
projects and start effective actions. The experience from many countries
and situations shows that a pool of financial resources from several
sources is the best possible solution to be searched. In this case, the
following configuration has been effective in projects and programmes in
both industrialized nations and developing countries:
- Support from international financing agencies.
- Support from local financing agencies and donor agencies.
- Participation of the private sector.
In this last component, the establishment of incentives for investing in
research and management can be a powerful tool to interest the private
sector in the joint financing process. The preparation of qualified human
resources also involves financial support from local donor agencies. In
Brazil, the experience of a professional MSc programme shared with
industry and university is becoming particularly suitable to solve
questions and problems related to water management and eutrophication
control. The cost of training is shared among public or private
universities, private industries, and companies.
Centres for Research, Innovation and Diffusion
Another experience that is relevant, once resources are pooled together
to solve several problems, is the implementation of Centres for Research,
Innovation, and Diffusion. One of the several institutional constraints
for the effective management of watersheds and water resources is the
compartment and sector approach that exists traditionally between the
generation of knowledge, the inclusion of private sector into the system,
and the diffusion of this knowledge to the community. This impairs the
availability of resources to the whole process, disrupts the chain between
knowledge/productive sector/community and slows down effective decisions
and actions.
In order to overcome these constraints, the establishment of centres for
research, innovation, and diffusion of knowledge are
probably the adequate institutional solutions. These centres would:
- Develop, intensively, research on the watershed as units implementing
a holistic overview of the system,
- interact with the community to promote new techniques for
dissemination of information,
- disseminate information to the general public,
- implement a training programmer for school teachers, managers,
decision-makers, components of private sector,
- interact with the private sector in order to develop mechanisms for
stimulating the involvement of private initiatives into the water
business, and supporting the establishment of small companies with a
high level of technological aggregation.
In this centre an incubator for private companies interested to develop
joint ventures with the academic sector can be implemented. This
experience is now underway in São Paulo State, Brazil with the
sponsorship of the São Paulo State Agency for Support of Research
(FAPESP), based on an earlier initiative of the National Science
Foundation in the U.S.A. The integration of the three activities in a
single centre, could be the solution for the optimization of financial and
human resources and implementation of management actions and diffusion.
Preparation of Case Studies
Case studies can be a useful tool for training at all levels. They can
be examples of planning and management practices taking into account
local/regional conditions, the existing advantages and constraints. Cases
studies can show the importance of database and scientific knowledge,
highlight the difficulties or facilities for articulations of the
partners, and provide a basis for a synthesis considering the integrative
process at the watershed level. Field experience in case studies is of
high value for the demonstration of successes and failures, institutional
constraints, and the need to a better interaction between policy and
instruments.
Institutional Networks
The establishment of institutional networks is an efficient mechanism to
pool resources for training, strengthen the databases, and enforce
integrative approaches. The networks coordinate efforts at regional or
sub-regional levels, link government institutions and private ones, and
provide a regional counterpart for international organizations that will
be part of the network. The international organizations support the
necessary links for the network, mainly exchange of personnel and access
to literature and other databases. To produce the "multiplier effect",
the existing structure should be used. It is vital to utilize the
experience, the human resources, and the institutions within each country
in order to assure continuity and build up expertise on a long-term basis.
International societies or federation of societies can provide support in
the form of professional expertise, resource persons, up dating of the
state-of-the-art.
|
 |
|