|
Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Planning and Management of Lakes and
Reservoirs: An Integrated Approach to Eutrophication>
CHAPTER 1. ENVIRONMENTAL ASPECTS OF EUTROPHICATION
1.4. Causes of Eutrophication
1.4.3. Results of Assessments of Eutrophication
When the data from mid-latitude freshwater lakes are combined with
information from lakes worldwide, it is evident that phosphorus limitation
is not universal in lakes and reservoirs. Regional differences in land use
and geochemistry can lead to ample supply of phosphorus. Within individual
lakes, seasonal variations in phosphorus and nitrogen supply are not
uncommon. Moreover, it is important to recognize that short-term
variations in the relative magnitude of various routes of nutrient supply
with different nitrogen to phosphorus ratios can change the importance of
nitrogen or phosphorus as limiting nutrients. Further, as lakes become
eutrophic, there is a tendency for nitrogen limitation to become more
important than in less nutrient-rich waters.
Based on the assumption that phosphorus is the primary limiting
nutrient, regression equations relating phosphorus, usually mean annual
total phosphorus, to algal biomass, usually expressed as mean annual
chlorophyll a, have been developed with the extensive data
available from freshwater lakes in north temperate and subarctic regions.
Similar relations have been found to apply in other areas, such as south
African and South American impoundment. However, the confidence interval
about the chlorophyll-phosphorus regressions can span an order of
magnitude. Apparently, limitation by nitrogen or light, differences in
nitrogen to phosphorus ratios and trophic structure among lakes can cause
substantial variability. Hence, relations between nutrients and
chlorophyll derived from regional data should be only one of several types
of evidence used in management decisions about the cause of
eutrophication.
Results from experimental enrichments used to assay for nitrogen or
phosphorus limitation are available from numerous freshwater lakes in the
north temperate region. Overall, combined nitrogen plus phosphorus
enrichments enhance algal growth more frequently and more substantially
than additions of nitrogen or phosphorus alone. Apparently, both nitrogen
and phosphorus are often in sufficiently short supply such that enrichment
with one without the other produces only a brief period of enhanced growth
before depletion of the not enriched nutrient limit growth. Although
nitrogen can be supplied from the atmosphere by fixation of gaseous
nitrogen, ecological constraints on gaseous nitrogen fixation may prevent
adequate rates of nitrogen supply via gaseous nitrogen fixation.
The role of nutrients in the eutrophication of temperate lakes in the
south hemisphere has been evaluated in a variety of lakes and reservoirs
in New Zealand, Australia and south Africa. In general, the lakes of New
Zealand have low total nitrogen to total phosphorus ratios and have about
half the nitrogen concentrations of comparable lakes in North America and
Europe. Lakes and reservoirs located in the semi-arid regions of south
Africa and Australia tend to be phosphorus limited to a greater extent
than lakes and reservoirs located in the semi-arid southwest United
States. Impoundment with low nutrient concentrations were usually
phosphorus limited, and, as phosphorus loading increased, nitrogen
limitation became more pronounced.
Systematic evaluation of the role of nutrient limitation in tropical
lakes is not possible because too few of the wide variety of tropical
lakes have been examined. East African lakes have received relatively more
attention than other lakes. Nitrogen limitation may be widespread because
of the low nitrate concentrations and moderate to high phosphate
concentrations common in eastern African lakes. However, nitrogen to
phosphorus ratios and uptake rates of radioactive phosphorus provide
strong evidence for phosphorus limitation in some Kenyan lakes. In South
American tropical floodplain lakes, seasonal and regional differences in
the relative importance of nitrogen or phosphorus limitation occur.
Concentrations of both total nitrogen and total phosphorus in South
American reservoirs correlate with chlorophyll. Physiological assays and
enrichment experiments carried out in Lake Titicaca, Boliva and Peru
provide good evidence for adequate phosphorus supply, while increased
algal growth after nitrogen additions occurred in Lake Valencia,
Venezuela.
|