Newsletter and Technical Publications
<Municipal Solid Waste Management>
Regional Overviews and Information Sources
Europe
2.3 Topic f: Special wastes
Separation of hazardous waste from MSW
There is a wide range of practice in the handling of household hazardous
waste (HHW) in Europe, and in its separation from MSW. In Northern European
countries, like Germany, the Netherlands, and Switzerland, the use of traveling
chemocars, vans equipped to collect HHW, is widespread. A typical scheme for
collection of HHW, which includes oil, is monthly collection in each
neighborhood, with the chemocar standing in a shopping center for a few hours at
the end of the route.
The overall trend in Europe seems to be to provide a convenient, frequent,
and reliable opportunity for separation of HHW. Where there is drop-off of waste
or recyclables, it is common to set up permanent acceptance sites for HHW, and
most drop-off centers include such facilities.
The collection of batteries, sometimes considered to be a part of HHW, is
usually handled separately. In many countries in Northern Europe, a purchaser
will be asked at the time of battery purchase to turn in the batteries he or she
is replacing. In the Netherlands and Germany, glass igloos often include a small
container for batteries. Batteries in Europe are recycled for their metals.
Also, the use of rechargeables appears to be growing, together with the
availability of simple, relatively low-cost rechargers.
Construction and demolition debris (C&D)
In general, European countries reclaim more construction and demolition waste
than other regions. Europe's dense population and old urban infrastructure lend
themselves well to intensive recovery. A second factor is the long experience in
brick and stone construction. In Northern Europe, the combination of increasing
reliance on incineration and the rapidly escalating weight-based landfill
tipping fees for non-combustible C&D combine to discourage both waste
haulers and contractors from disposing of materials that can be recovered.
Furthermore, C&D waste has been the focus of a number of policy initiatives
in the last several years, and the concept of producer responsibility is an
influence here as well.
Increasingly, European construction and demolition sites are served by a
multi-container waste removal system, which allows the contractor to source
separate recoverable and non-recoverable materials. In regions where this has
not yet become accepted practice, waste hauling firms are likely to separate
recoverable materials in a separation plant, using some combination of
mechanical and manual separation. The most common configuration involves a
tipping floor for the materials, which are then partially separated by a loader
or bulldozer to remove the oversize or clearly recoverable materials, such as
cardboard (generated in large quantities in C&D waste streams). The
remaining materials are either pushed into a pit conveyor or loaded in to a
hopper conveyor, where they are separated by hand, usually in conjunction with
one or more shredding or milling steps. Magnetic separation is also common,
especially at the end of the separation process, after size reduction. Where
facilities for separation are not available, and economics are favorable (that
is, disposal is expensive), limited separation on the tipping floor of transfer
stations is not unusual.
Recoverable C&D materials in Europe include brick, concrete, stone, wood,
and construction-related paper products. Except for wood and paper, most of
these materials are crushed in sophisticated stone-crushing plants (similar to
those associated with the quarrying of virgin stone), screened to standard
sizes, and resold into the market for construction, paving, and other materials.
Wood is frequently shredded for mulch, although there is a body of opinion that
states that the most environmentally sound disposal strategy for wood, because
of its high BTU content, is combustion in a waste-to-energy facility. In
deforested, wood-poor countries like Spain, there is a potential for the use of
waste wood in domestic cooking and heating. Paper, consisting primarily of kraft
paper and corrugated cardboard, is often pulled off the tipping floor, if it is
not source-separated, and baled for marketing to traditional paper markets.
Recently, there have been some efforts to recover, bale, and market the
polyethylene sheeting used in the packaging of construction material pallets,
together with the sheeting used to protect curing concrete from rain.
Tires
Western Europe generates well over 100 million waste tires per year. The
European Commission, although giving attention to waste tires, has not yet
produced either a recommendation or a directive for its member nations.
Although Europeans are suffering from a theoretical tire disposal crisis, the
sorts of tire piles sometimes seen in North America are not widely in evidence,
except, to some degree, in the UK. Some countries, such as the Netherlands, have
extremely high rates of retreading, even of passenger tires, and there is a
small amount of reclaiming. Retreading rates of 25-30% are not uncommon in
Europe, and in some countries, they are higher.
Where reclamation possibilities do not exist, the recognized tire disposal
option in Europe is either burning in a waste-to-energy facility or burial,
after shredding, in a landfill. European Union laws and regulations continue to
restrict these options, due in part to concern over operational and
environmental consequences of too many tires in the disposal stream.
In some more southern European countries, like Greece, Portugal, and Spain,
fewer waste tires are generated, since there are fewer cars, and the tires are
used for longer. In the Naples, Italy region, there are a large number of
small-scale tire reclamation businesses, including several that re-groove bus
and truck tires.
Used oil
Used oil is considered neither a hazardous waste nor a "normal"
solid waste in much of Europe. Many European drop-off centers offer used-oil
depots, and some countries have special containers placed near glass igloos and
other drop-off facilities. In most countries, certain if not all gas stations
and retail outlets take oil back in point-of-purchase collection programs. Waste
oil is accepted in most household hazardous waste programs, but waste oil
containers are not generally considered hazardous. Improperly disposed of oil is
considered so dangerous in densely populated Europe that at least one country,
Austria, has prohibited do-it-yourself oil changes to force all used oil to be
removed in gas stations, where it can be separately collected and recycled.
Medical and hospital waste
The overwhelming majority of hospital waste in Western Europe is incinerated,
in incinerators meeting stringent air pollution control standards; this is the
ideal for Eastern European countries as well. In many Western European nations,
air pollution control regulations are forcing a shift from smaller, on-site,
hospital-based incinerators to larger, regional medical waste incinerators with
acid gas scrubbers and electrostatic precipitators or baghouses. Some
governments, like that of Switzerland, have a bias against on-site incineration,
as pollution control equipment is seldom affordable at a small scale.
Both dedicated regional medical waste incinerators and waste-to-energy plants
figure in the disposal of European medical waste. A German innovation co-locates
smaller, dedicated medical waste incinerators on the sites of high-tech
waste-to-energy facilities, and cycles their waste gases through the pollution
control system of the larger installation. In Germany and Sweden, there is in
some cases 100% redundancy, meaning that there is a fully capable backup
incinerator which can burn all medical wastes. It is not usual for dedicated
medical waste incinerators, which are designed in the same manner as hazardous
waste incinerators, to recover energy. In rare cases, the older practice of
sterilization or autoclaving before landfilling is used as an alternative.
Formerly, many hospitals had their own on-site incinerators, and in some
places this is still the case, although these smaller incinerators are
increasingly being phased out as appropriate regional waste-to-energy capacity
becomes available.
Sewage sludge
Sewage sludge is arguably not a waste stream, but a product of waste
processing. Sewage sludge is a product of primary or secondary wastewater
treatment, and is usually generated in the form of a moist, cake-like substance
whose moisture content varies from 40% to 60% by weight.
There are six general options for sludge handling, four of which produce an
inter-mediate substance or product, which must be further handled through
processing or land application. These are: (a) land application without
treatment; (b) neutralization, using lime or other substances; (c) drying; (d)
composting or co-composting; (e) incineration; and (f) landfilling and/or use as
a cover material in landfill management.
Europeans employ all of these methods. When mixed MSW composting was a more
important waste processing strategy, the co-composting of sludge with this
material was more common, since the moisture content and high nitrogen of the
sludge was able to complement and offset the dryness and high carbon content of
the paper in the waste stream. The decrease in co-composting, in part due to the
implementation of high compost standards, means that more sludge must be handled
in other ways.
Where incinerators are available, incineration of sludge is deemed helpful in
reducing the combustibility of excessively combustible waste streams.
|